4 ms·
True, but I'm at a loss to see how the safety interests of Canadians are threatened by Chelsea Manning. It's not like she's violent or carried out a crime again
by anigbrowl 5y ago
True, but I'm at a loss to see how the safety interests of Canadians are threatened by Chelsea Manning. It's not like she's violent or carried out a crime against members of the public. The crime, being against the state, was as much political as the commutation.
- tptacek 5y agoCanada wasn't threatened by either of the friends of mine who weren't allowed into the country because of previous criminal convictions. The article isn't wrong when it points out that this occurs routinely. Why is it only wrong when it impacts someone with a cheering section? People will say "it isn't only wrong then!", but they're only angry... situationally.
- perl4ever 5y ago>they're only angry... situationally. You don't know, though! I mean, not everybody gets angry that easy, but many are aware that you don't have to commit a crime or do something wrong to be barred from crossing an international border. I remember an article by a woman who was turned back from Canada because she had antidepressant medication with her.
- tptacek 5y agoI spent a couple years working for a company in Calgary, with a staff mostly from the US, and this was a recurring concern. It's not a thing that just started for Chelsea Manning.
- perl4ever 5y agoWhat was a recurring concern? Politics? Psych meds? Commuted or expunged convictions?
- tptacek 5y agoThat it was not a given that members of our team would be allowed past immigration control at the airport in Calgary.
- perl4ever 5y agoA co-worker of mine went to Pakistan and unexpectedly couldn't get readmitted to the US for years. At least the company kept him on, working remotely.
- pbourke 5y agoCanadians living in the US on work visas have the same worries when reentering the US.
- tptacek 5y agoNo doubt! Absolutely true! We were ultimately acquired by an American company, and American immigration rules caused problems for the Canadians. My point isn't that Canada is distinctively bad; it's that this story has nothing the hell to do with Chelsea Manning.
- perl4ever 5y ago>this story has nothing the hell to do with Chelsea Manning I mean, no need to debate it, who knows, but I think you're exaggerating your certainty. It's possible that this has an additional political dimension, even though similar things can happen without it.
- tptacek 5y agoI don't think I'm exaggerating at all. Canada routinely bars entry to convicted felons from the US. Manning is famously a felon. This is what irritates me about this story; the people making the most noise about it don't care at all about the ordinary ex-convicts that Canada bars, just this celebrity.
- Gibbon1 5y agoFriend of mine was denied entry for six months because she was born in Iran. Her family fled to Britain when she was 2. At the time she'd been living and working in the US for 10 years.
- anigbrowl 5y agoI'm sure it wasn't, but I know nothing about your friends. I was responding to these specific statements of the GP: Outside of that, a presidential commuted sentence, by its very nature, is political, not court based. Lastly, each country puts the safety of its citizens, above the rights of foreigners to visit. I am not a cheerleader for Chelsea Manning, who I have sympathy for in some respects but dislike in others.
- tptacek 5y agoIt may be that I'm just using your comment as a convenient coat rack for my own frustration with the framing here. Canada is doing something that it has done consistently for decades without any comment from this community (or really many other communites). But then they do it to Chelsea Manning, and now we're discussing a headline "Canada aims to block Chelsea Manning". Actually, Chelsea Manning has better odds of being let into Canada than a lot of "boring" people with felony convictions. And that's kind of a problem.
- simion314 5y agoI read HN first page almost daily, for international news I read BBC, I am from Romania, Eastern Europe sand I had no idea that this happened to your friends or for other people. Canada does not popup that much in the international news. Maybe I missed a similar article on HN were the majority had the exact oposite reaction like in this one?
- mikeryan 5y agoI’d think that it’s not about her safety. It’s about a policy of saying “we don’t allow people with felony convictions in”. Which seems sensible to me. There’s not an immigration service in the world who wants to choose which felonies should be enforced on a case by case basis and generally not a populace who believes that fame should get you a golden ticket. Would I personally let her in? Sure! If I ran an immigration department? Nope.