5 ms·
> Fusion is what reduces energy cost potentially another 10x How did you arrive at that conclusion?
by pfdietz 5y ago
> Fusion is what reduces energy cost potentially another 10x
How did you arrive at that conclusion?
- stjohnswarts 5y agoProbably counting in the cost of unlimited global warming and all the damage it will do if we don't stop it, which we won't if current efforts are par for the course.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pfdietz 5y agoThat would make sense if he's comparing only against fossil fuels. But what was written was: > I like to think of solar, batteries, fission, and wind as compelling ways to go mostly carbon free and lower energy costs about 2x over the next 20 years or so. > Fusion is what reduces energy cost potentially another 10x, which really changes the game for lots of things. Exciting stuff. Kudos to this team. If the 10x is from avoiding fossil fuels, why does fusion get that credit, but the other non-fossil sources don't?
- Nevermark 5y ago> which we won't if current efforts are par for the course. Because while renewable energy production is increasing rapidly, it is nowhere where we need it to cancel fossil fuels. Nothing will be soon enough. That would have been now or ten years ago. But anything that gets us there sooner will reduce the damage we have done, and fingers crossed, allow us to start undoing it.
- olau 5y agoIf you have a cheap means to an end or an expensive one, and you have limited funding because of politics, you will want to pour all your money into scaling the cheap means - then you'll get there much, much faster. I live close to a wind turbine factory. They could easily have scaled production multiple times over the past five years. The only reason they didn't is funding, in fact during that period they at some point cut production when subsidies were cut. I think it's getting to a point now where subsidies are not needed. But still, if you're talking about speeding up the process, you can just provide a little extra funding and get big results.
- ncmncm 5y agoAnybody looking at numbers sees fusion never, ever producing so much as a single erg of commercially viable energy. So, anybody saying otherwise is simply making it up.
- craftinator 5y ago> So, anybody saying otherwise is simply making it up. You do see the irony of embedding this statement in a comment full of generalization and hyperbole, and lacking any evidence or credible sources, right? I genuinely laughed until I realized it may not have been intended as a joke.
- vajrabum 5y agoWhat numbers are those? Or perhaps you even have a citation from work done on the topic by reputable physicists?
- tcmart14 5y agoAnd neither did any other invention until they reached a certain scale, price point or level of sophistication. The counter to your comment would be, fusion is still very much in the R&D phase. As being in the R&D phase like so many other products were at one time, of course it has not met your expectation. But neither did Airplanes after the first flight.
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoThe sun does pretty well.
- wiz21c 5y agoExcept we didn't need to invest money in it...
- tuatoru 5y agoYeah, really, how? Fusion power plants still need land, buildings, generators, switchyards, wire, own power consumption, environmental impact reports, planning permits, regulations, inspections, and all the rest. And they need exotic materials and weird engineering in their construction. Really: how does fusion get us to ~1% (correction: ~5%) of current power prices? I've never seen a convincing explanation. Usually it's bare assertion. Infrequently it's handwavium/unobtanium.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoOne of the big problems with existing power plants is that you have to build them near where people are. So then land is expensive and you get a bunch of regulations because people are worried about what's happening in their back yard. If you could hypothetically build a fusion plant that would generate several times more power than existing fission reactors at a similar construction cost, you would have so much power you wouldn't have to worry much about transmission losses. At which point you could put it in the middle of nowhere without those constraints and make it actually less expensive for several times more power. Then for cities power gets cheaper, but for anything that can be built out in the middle of nowhere near the reactor, power gets a lot cheaper.
- tuatoru 5y agoHow is that reasoning specific to fusion? Unless fusion power is dramatically more efficient than other thermal plants, like 99.9%, your bigger plant will still need massive heat removal structures and systems, which means siting them near water. All the good spots are already taken. Alternatively you can use truly massive air heat transfer structures, driving up your construction costs again. I neglected to mention finance costs also. With an untried technology the rate of return demanded is going to be very high, further driving up project costs.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> How is that reasoning specific to fusion? A major cost of the most utilized existing power plants (coal and natural gas) is fuel. If you build a natural gas plant which is twice as big so that you can put it out where the land is cheaper and eat the transmission losses, now you need twice as much natural gas. Renewables don't need fuel but their construction cost is fully linear, you get no economies of scale. If you want twice as many solar panels then you need twice as much land. If you want to double the size of your fusion reactor, you build an eight story building instead of a four story building on the same piece of land. > Unless fusion power is dramatically more efficient than other thermal plants, like 99.9%, your bigger plant will still need massive heat removal structures and systems, which means siting them near water. All the good spots are already taken. An obvious solution is to build them out in the ocean. Then you have plenty of water and you're still not near anything. And the good spots near population centers are already taken. Some lake a hundred miles from any city won't be. > I neglected to mention finance costs also. With an untried technology the rate of return demanded is going to be very high, further driving up project costs. That's only true for the first one. If it's hypothetically ten times more power for the same money, that'll get one built even at a high interest rate. Then once you have it running it's proven technology.
- godelski 5y agoResponding for the parent. They are basically making predictions with S curves. Technology often starts out as really expensive but after awhile gets super cheap, following what appears to be an exponential curve (bottom of the S), before it levels off (top of the S). Yeah, look more like an integral sign or sigmoid. But with fusion the endless claims of "too cheap to meter" are because how much energy there is in a fusion reaction. [0] We know that fission produces a lot of energy (but is expensive) but fusion produces significantly more. It also doesn't have the radiation drawbacks and so it is expected to follow the S curve (fission did initially but things changed. This is part of why France has so much nuclear). So if (big if) fusion does follow this S curve (which there are good reasons to expect it to) then it could provide a very cheap and sustainable energy source. Yes, it is a bet, but every technology is. We won't know until we spend significant time and money into researching it. But honestly, a few billion dollars isn't that crazy for the potential upsides. We've spent that money on far greater risks with lower payout. Despite what the OP said, the money for ITER does not require international collaboration. Any rich country could do it themselves. [0] (Fission and fusion can yield energy graph) http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/NucEne/nucbin.html http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/NucEne/nucbin.htm...
- brazzledazzle 5y agoIf we got to the point where cost wasn't a factor would the carbon footprint be extremely low? I assume at some point we'll be unable to ignore climate change and our survival will depended on minimizing it using large amounts of energy from a source that doesn't have a high carbon footprint.
- Terr_ 5y agoIf only ~30% of CO2 emissions are from power-plants (at least in the US, probably higher globally considering developing nations) then replacing those installations with fusion won't directly zero things out... ... But if "cost wasn't a factor" then we could just simply dedicate the electrical output of fusion plants to brute-force CO2 out of the air.
- 5y ago