3 ms·
Thanks for sharing this anecdote, I remember it from when you've posted about it in the past and it's stuck with me. > I have donated to police in the last cou
by heavyset_go 5y ago
Thanks for sharing this anecdote, I remember it from when you've posted about it in the past and it's stuck with me.
> I have donated to police in the last couple/few years, so... there's that... which may come to an end.
In my opinion, there's a good reason for it to come to an end that has nothing to do with this.
In the states I'm familiar with, PBAs and police unions were the top (and sometimes only) spenders when it came to lobbying against marijuana legalization. They use those donations to lobby and ensure that they can continue to arrest, fine and imprison scores of people for victimless crimes, while also ensuring their job security in doing so.
- artificialLimbs 5y agoUgh now I feel dirty...
- heavyset_go 5y agoIn one state where legalization was approved by public mandate, the legislation that passed made it so anyone under the age of 21 could only receive a warning for possession, and no charges or arrests. This is important because any drug arrests, charges or convictions make individuals ineligible for federal student loans or assistance for college, meaning the kids who do get arrested might have their plans to better their lives ruined by a cop who doesn't like the smell of marijuana. Police unions spent months and millions of dollars lobbying the state government so that they could still arrest and charge kids for pot possession.
- tomc1985 5y ago> Police unions spent months and millions of dollars lobbying the state government so that they could still arrest and charge kids for pot possession. But why though? Hatred? Inertia? Culture? Do they get paid per scalp? Do they love their drug dogs that much? The lack of arguments against pot-smoking notwithstanding, what is it that backs this? Because so much of this seems completely arbitrary.
- vageli 5y agoIt seems akin to a petty gatekeeper in a large organization—encroachment on a domain under their control is viewed as an existential threat.
- heavyset_go 5y agoIn that state, a significant amount of arrests, convictions and revenue from fines came from marijuana charges. Each conviction came with hundreds to thousands in fines. Not only that, each conviction created busywork for probation officers, as low level offenders were given the option to have their record cleaned of their conviction if they went on probation programs where they are drug tested regularly. The probation program came with more fines/fees, as well. It also opened opportunities to keep people in the system, because violation of probation has its own penalties. Kids' parents have the incentive to push kids through this program and to pay for it, too. There are those reasons, and then there's the simple fact that cops know they will have less to do if they can't arrest people for pot, which might be bad for job security. Losing "I smell marijuana" as a method for establishing probable cause was a big deal, as well.
- michaelmrose 5y agoArresting you improves their metrics and helps justify the labor hours that ultimately pay their bills. Also it's used as a pretext to steal billions of dollars via civil asset forfeiture much of it in less than $1000 increments. See literal highway robbers stealing $500 from citizens via lawsuits like state vs 535 dollars and 75 cents where criminal intent is inferred but no proof is given.
- oneplane 5y agoThe whole idea that there can be some monetary flow in to the police based on what types of things they do seems baffling to me. Donating to a governmental apparatus? That's just asking for influence and abuse. Don't like what the cops do? Threaten to pull some multi-million 'donation' and suddenly everything becomes possible. At that point it's not law enforcement but money enforcement. Same as being a cop: need more money? Bust some people for whatever happens to be convenient and 'make money' on off of that. The only money should be coming from the government, and everything they collect should be going back into the government. If you turn it into a corporate system where money is a motivator you're doomed from the start.
- maxerickson 5y agoThere's political organizations that advocate for police. It would be an infringement of speech rights to prevent people from donating to them, at least as they are currently defined in the US.
- avs733 5y agoAnd it should be one that we tolerate. There are lots of infringements on speech, especially professional speech. The idea that somehow a group empowered by the state to commit violence in defense of the states policies have a more sacrosanct right to speech than doctors or teachers is absurd. These aren’t individuals speaking as individuals…this is effectively government speech and we ought not wrong our hands about restricting it. The government has no right to speech.
- maxerickson 5y agoThere are equivalent groups for doctors and teachers, I don't follow your meaning. Like what is it that FOP¹ does that you think they should be prevented from doing? Should they not be allowed to exist? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraternal_Order_of_Police https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraternal_Order_of_Police Please note that I don't give money to these organizations, I'm pointing out what a big chunk of donating money to the police consists of.