5 ms·
"Come and take them." No, I am not saying to start shooting at the cops if they ask for this. I am saying to refuse, go to jail if they require it, then meet
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
"Come and take them."
No, I am not saying to start shooting at the cops if they ask for this. I am saying to refuse, go to jail if they require it, then meet them in court, accusing them of wrongful arrest and violation of the 4th Amendment.
[Edit: This approach can get you in trouble that can take you years to get out of. Don't follow it if you aren't willing to face that.]
- tptacek 5y agoOn what basis could the police arrest you, let alone jail you, for not telling them what your Twitter account is?
- prepend 5y agoObstruction of justice.
- Cycl0ps 5y agoFailure to comply with commands given by an officer. Suspicious activity. Belligerent conduct. Whether these are actual charges or not don't even matter, as officers aren't legally required (by supreme court decision) to understand the law they enforce. If they want to arrest you they can. So to restate your question: On what basis do the police think they can arrest you?
- tptacek 5y agoIt is not the case that you can be lawfully arrested simply for failing to comply with any given command given by an officer. See, for instance, the last 10 years of case law regarding people recording the police despite their urgent demands that they stop. It's fair to point out that the police can arrest you unlawfully, and that's a real risk you run when saying "no" to them. But it's important to know that saying "no" to a request for your Twitter account name is legally very safe, and that the police would be way out over their skis arresting you for doing that. Being detained for questioning is not a big deal, but being arrested is a very big deal, and it does not happen as casually as message boards think it does. If the police routinely arrest people without lawful cause, there are consequences (though they aren't the consequences any of us would hope there'd be).
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoAre there consequences to them for detaining you for no good reason? Because that seems to me to be their best strategy if someone refuses to give them their social media accounts. Make it kind of costly, but not to the point where the officer involved gets in any trouble.
- tptacek 5y agoI'm not a lawyer. There are more- and less- formal restrictions on how long they can detain you, but my mental model is just that they can detain you for basically any reason --- it is not my claim that there are magic words that can get the police to go away, or to stop asking you questions, and you might just have to put up with it until they get tired of you. The next step, though, where they trundle you off to a police station for interrogation --- that's an arrest. It's a big deal. Actual cause is needed.
- Cycl0ps 5y agoYou've made good points on this. My concern would be that police officers have an obligation to gather this information as it states in the article, and that they would lean on their powers to detain and arrest in order to coerce that information. Let's run through a hypothetical. Routine traffic stop. Cop pulls out one of these cards and asks for your handles. You refuse, claim Miranda rights, or something similar. Cop says you, "match the description of a known suspect" (in a city as large as LA everyone matches a known suspect) and this is part of the ID process. "Of course, we can do a check using the computers at the station but you'll need to come with us until we confirm your ID ..." Now, following through on that threat is an arrest, but under California law police have 48-hours to investigate before either charging you with a crime or releasing you. I doubt most officers would use the entire time, but letting someone stew for the afternoon in a drunk tank seems entirely within reason. During that time their car has been impounded and they're either missing work or missing time with their loved ones. Refusing to self identify could carry an effective fine in the hundreds of dollars, and that worries me.
- datameta 5y agoObstruction of justice. Alternatively, suspicion of intoxication. The list isn't short.
- tptacek 5y agoRefusing to answer an arbitrary question from a police officer is not in fact obstruction of justice. You don't have to wonder what the elements of "obstruction" are; you can look them up. Here, by the way, it's helpful to know that California doesn't even have an "obstruction of justice" statute (it has "Resisting arrest laws", which you can read more about to see that not giving your Twitter account up is not going to get you convicted of that).
- yata69420 5y agoYou're asking the wrong question. On what basis could you stop police from arresting you, let alone jailing you, for any reason they see fit? The answer involves a lawyer, a lot of time, a lot of money, and low expectations.
- artificialLimbs 5y agoYou can't technically, but if they do so without probable cause then they stand to get smacked down in court and pay heavy fines to the person they falsely arrest.
- Sebb767 5y agoThis will still be a very unpleasant time for you, with more consequences down the line (you might miss work, for example). And if the officer can convince the judge that they truly thought arresting you was reasonable, you won't get much in the way of compensation, either. Lastly, the fines don't get paid by the officer themself, so even if it is a full smack down, it won't hurt too much.
- elliekelly 5y agoThey got this guy on (criminal!) failure to register his bicycle: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=28w6xvRj9EM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=28w6xvRj9EM
- literallyaduck 5y agoThere is a saying "You can beat the rap, but not the ride." They can make things very unpleasant. Voting out the people who are allowing this is very important.
- base698 5y agoVoting got us here, but more voting is a solution?
- jdavis703 5y agoI do believe so. There were many candidates that ran on a reform or defund the police platform (careful though, there were also some who were accused of doing so, but weren’t.) Some of them even won elections last year.
- literallyaduck 5y agoThere is another saying, "it is not vote that counts, but who counts the votes." We need to push for transparency in all aspects of elections, if someone says fraud, we need to be able to have evidence that no fraud occurred that is indisputable. Anyone should be able to examine the proof. The hard part is to provide anonymity and transparency. The harder part is getting people to agree to making transparency and accountability part of the process without one side or another providing a back door to the process.
- anigbrowl 5y agoI don't think so; I believe it's foolish to expect to solve 21st century political problems with 18th century political technology. I think concepts like a wikiocracy and contractual citizenship of virtualized territory are where things are headed in the longer term. The notion that you'll get good results by delegating all your political power to a representative for a period of years is asinine on its face, doubly so when their decision-making is subject to all sorts of perverse incentives, no matter how decent of a person they are. That seemed viable in a bygone era where the pace of change was glacial, to the extent that the America of 1776 would have been easily comprehensible to a Roman or Greek time traveler. In the early days of the American Republic, legal issues fo rhte average person did not change so much from before, except insofar as royal prerogative no longer existed. Many of the early landmark legal cases were about matters of state rather than relations between individuals and the state (obviously a generalization for the sake of brevity). Over time the US (and other state) legal systems have inexorably grown in volume and complexity, for reasons that are still debated but ably summarized here: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-73623-x https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-73623-x This increase comes at a cognitive cost, both for individuals who enter or are caught up in the legal system, and for lawmakers and those who elect them. Endless patching with no practical opportunity for refactoring or rewriting in a situation that should be familiar to most HN readers and whose outcomes are quite predictable: either you freeze the code and it becomes increasingly brittle as the environment continues to change around it, or the code turns into an unmanageable mess that is in various aspects oppressive, corrupted, or exploitable by different actors, and social goods of coherence and predictability are inexorably eroded, a situation in which we arguably find ourselves at present. Radicals of all political stripes (including myself) regard this as unsustainable but disagree on the values and mechanism that ought to replace it. Those who insist that everything is working fine and as the founders intended tend to be either successful collectors of political rents or naive optimists who have never seriously experienced or imagined life under other conditions, , like users of a software tool who have never felt any need to explore the preferences dialog or examine the paradigmatic foundation of the tools they've learned to use.