2 ms·
Comparing how much money Disney, Netflix and the BBC put into productions is useless. Netflix in particular has already burned a lot of money and the result was
by croes 5y ago
Comparing how much money Disney, Netflix and the BBC put into productions is useless.
Netflix in particular has already burned a lot of money and the result was average at best. How many failures are there for a hit like "The Crown", how long can Netflix in particular continue to spend so much money?
For quality, you need the right makers, and the BBC has often had the right ones.
- chrisseaton 5y agoBut I think this is where it's starting to nose-dive. It used to be there were competitors but they were crass comparative junk, like ITV. Now the competitors are suddenly massively out BBC-ing the BBC. Huge landmark period dramas - used to be only the BBC could competently pull that off. Now Netflix does it better. Serious radio discussion - used to be only found on the BBC. Now I can get it often better from Spectator or New Statesman podcasts. They're being out-done on money and talent in, and results out, for their own game. Really serious problem.
- croes 5y agoWait and see. Netflix was once the place for new fresh shows but it's a victim of it's shareholders value. Most shows don't survive the 1st season. If the BBC tries to copy Netflix they will lose, if they stick to their last it might work out.
- mrkstu 5y agoApple seems to be trying to occupy the quality niche though.
- chrisseaton 5y agoIt’s the quality thing - previously peopled tried to compete with the BBC by being lower brow, now they’re attacking the high brow.
- echelon 5y agoIt's insane to me that Apple and Amazon are making movies. How many things are companies allowed to do? They're clearly making it harder for other players in these markets, and they're leveraging their insane capital to succeed in areas they have no experience in. It's also incredibly annoying now that there are a dozen different subscription services, each with different apps and radically different navigation UX, and many of which don't run on the same hardware. This is insane.
- whimsicalism 5y ago> they're leveraging their insane capital to succeed in areas they have no experience in. This is nothing unique about Apple and Amazon, leveraging insane capital is the name of the game.
- echelon 5y agoIt's wildly anticompetitive. And let's not forget that this isn't strictly about movies, but the broader concept of attention. The giants are paying to keep attention on their platforms, and they're doing it in every vertical they can possibly enter. This makes it hard for other industries to compete for that same attention as they don't have the claws and meat hooks that the trillionaire famgopolies do. How does MGM compete? They can't. They sell their assets on the cheap to the rich megamonopoly.
- caoilte 5y agoPutting aside my consternation that the spectator is capable of serious discussion (it recently published an article in defence of Greek neo-nazis), the fiction that until recently only the BBC could pull off "huge landmark period dramas" is simply propaganda put about by media barons wrestling with raging hard ons for Ayn Rand in their Riviera villas (eg Brideshead Revisited - ITV 1981).
- zabzonk 5y ago> BBC has often had the right ones. "had" being the operative word here.
- croes 5y agoEven Netflix and Disney can't buy them all.
- mabub24 5y agoThe big distinguishing factor has long been Netflix's subscriber driven business model: if they're not growing in subscribers then the company appears to be "failing" or stagnant to investors/shareholders. Netflix's original productions are for retention, but moreso for getting new subscribers to boost the subscription numbers (hence their hard push into Asia). Netflix's problem is that it doesn't have the niche of another service using the same business model, something like HBO which makes "HBO shows" (Nudity, violence, swearing, "prestige" productions). Without a distinct house style or niche aesthetic, Netflix has adopted the firehose method. Blast as much money at as many scripts as possible with the hopes that one will turn gold. The BBC, through the licensing fee, kind of evades that business model and the ramifications of it; the BBC can choose to not aim for "hits", but for cultural content as such. Creators are free to create cultural content without a direct profit motive and that really allows the BBC to retain some very high quality documentarians, screenwriters, producers, and directors. The licensing fee is a tax, but it is a tax that keeps the profit motive from dominating media production.