3 ms·
"So you're going to argue both sides of the question? You're really going to argue that every trick in the book has been tried, and that the amount that non-lyi
by jerf 15y ago
"So you're going to argue both sides of the question? You're really going to argue that every trick in the book has been tried, and that the amount that non-lying economists recommended to spend wasn't feasible?"
Actually, they're all of a kind. One of my core problems with Keynesianism is that you must treat "government investment opportunities" like any other resource; you've got low hanging fruit, where you put in a dollar and get $4 in wealth back, you've got a series of barely-above-break-even, then a sea of places you can put a dollar and get back $0.75. You can't just assume that because you've spent a dollar under duress you're getting more than a dollar back in value; economics is built on that but the logic only holds when one is freely choosing to spend the dollar because you expect to get more than a dollar back.
Keynesianism isn't about just spending wildly, it's all about spending where you get over-unity results, and even if I believed in the power of a massive centralized authority to correct determine where those opportunities are (which I don't), there's a huge problem with that, which is that we already spent a large number of those dollars on those over-unity projects. We don't hang around in the boom times and let our roads go to pot on purpose so that when the recession comes we have good investment opportunities for stimulus. It is unlikely that that is even a good idea. So the goverment is trying to stimulate into a market where the low-hanging fruit is mostly gone anyways.
Maybe this works in 1930. Maybe this works in the Third World. In a developed country there's [feasible] no way to PRODUCTIVELY spend three trillion dollars. Now... UNproductive spending we can do, but even under the dictates of Keynesianism that's a bad idea! Sucking a dollar out of the economy (as debt or taxes) to get back $0.75 in value is simply a straight-up net loss.
I find the theory that government spending is producing a lot of net loss of wealth dovetails rather nicely with the real economic results we are experiencing, as opposed to the predictions of those who are implementing this policy.
21st century Keynesianism has some enormous leaps of logic in it that I have not been able to follow wherein it is simply assumed that the government can find things to spend that are stimulative. I'm not even sure where this stuff is supposed to come from, even in theory. You can't even just wave around the word "crumbling infrastructure" because you can't just wave a wand and make everybody a construction worker, so you're bounded there.
Every trick was tried, and that only got us a hundred billion or so, so our politicians just kept spending more anyhow. Guess what? It's disastrous, not stimulative, and as far as I can tell, even Keynes would have said so in advance.