4 ms·
But purely from performance point of view, as in throughput, and also quality of service, the case is clear for the mainframe. No, it isn't clear. Show the ben
by wmf 5y ago
But purely from performance point of view, as in throughput, and also quality of service, the case is clear for the mainframe.
No, it isn't clear. Show the benchmarks.
- belter 5y agoPlease note I am talking about the mainframe as a platform. We can start here: "IBM z15 Performance of Cryptographic Operations" https://www.ibm.com/downloads/cas/6K2653EJ https://www.ibm.com/downloads/cas/6K2653EJ Can your x86 do this? Edit: "Introducing the new IBM z15 T02" https://www.ibm.com/training/pdfs/The_New_IBM_z15_A-technical_review_of_the_Processor_Design_New_Features_IO_Cards_and_Crypto_2020.pdf https://www.ibm.com/training/pdfs/The_New_IBM_z15_A-technica... ========== 5.2 GHz core frequency • On-chip compression accelerator (NXU) • On Core L1/L2 Cache • L2-I from 2MB to 4MB per core • On chip L3 Cache • L3 from 128MB to 256MB per chip 960 MB shared eDRAM L4 Cache =========
- belter 5y agoAlso a comparison of Z15 Java performance vs x86. The advantage for the mainframe comes from the additional computing capabilities like compression dedicated hardware and other components the x86 platform misses. https://github.com/IBM/IBM-Z-zOS/blob/main/zOS-Education/Hints-and-Tips-for-Java-on-zOS/Java%20on%20z15%20-%20Performance%20Overview.pdf https://github.com/IBM/IBM-Z-zOS/blob/main/zOS-Education/Hin...
- trasz 5y agoYou still hadn't mentioned any relevant number.
- belter 5y ago"Linux Workload Performance on LinuxONE III / z15" https://community.ibm.com/HigherLogic/System/DownloadDocumentFile.ashx?DocumentFileKey=7da4d6d0-1d2d-457f-ec1c-a75e7346a6c9&forceDialog=0 https://community.ibm.com/HigherLogic/System/DownloadDocumen...
- Retric 5y agoOk the benchmark is from June 17th, 2020 but it’s using a Xeon 6140 a Skylake chip from Q3'17. That gets crushed even by even a $125.00 E5-2670 let alone whatever your similar budget buys you. So, I am guessing actual head to head benchmarks must be quite bad.
- belter 5y agoYes. It has a Processor Base Frequency 2.30 GHz · Max Turbo Frequency 3.70 GHz Your latest Intel® Xeon® E-2386G Processor, not available yet...has a base frequency of 3.50 GHz and a Max Turbo Frequency 5.10 GHz So even with the latest...your Turbo frequency... is the base from the mainframe core... And if you happen to be running a memory bound benchmark, with the massive caches in the mainframe, you will be crushed.
- Retric 5y ago> Running a memory bound benchmark I can easily write a memory bound benchmark that makes all CPU cache irrelevant. The only thing that actually matters is real world performance which is why actual benchmarks are so critical. > Xeon® E-2386G Processor That’s a chip from 2018. Anyway, you can talk about CPU clock speeds all day, but it doesn’t mean much between different CPU families.
- belter 5y agoCan't reply to response from Retric below so will do it here. Wrong choice indeed the Xeon® E-2386G Processor its not what I was looking for. Instead of going for the latest lets review the latest offers from Intel: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_processors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_processors A few models that have a peak turbo frequency approaching the sustained frequency of Z core. Also, of course due to different architectures, internal caches, we should not be comparing purely on frequency. Although the mainframe is again wining here in frequency and cache sizes... Also agree that what counts are real workloads with real commercial applications. I have so far posted at least three but here is another one: "IBM MQ for z/OS on z15 Performance" http://ibm-messaging.github.io/mqperf/MQ_for_zOS_on_z15.pdf http://ibm-messaging.github.io/mqperf/MQ_for_zOS_on_z15.pdf
- ptomato 5y agothey appear to be bragging about 12GiB/s of aes-256-gcm per crypto accelerator. This is equivalent performance to about 2.6 cores of epyc milan, but let's be generous and say 3 cores. At retail, 3 cores of epyc milan costs $240-$360. How much does one of those crypto accelerators cost?