9 ms·
So much security that not sense. I attend college football games. Everyone goes through security. Outside security we pack up in masses of humanity outside t
by duxup 5y ago
So much security that not sense.
I attend college football games. Everyone goes through security. Outside security we pack up in masses of humanity outside the gates waiting to get through the inevitably slow security.
It would be far more effective to do something at the gates dude to the density of humanity there where there is no security ... than in the stadium where people are actually more spread out.
If someone did want to do something at such a sporting event, nothing is stopping them from doing it at the gates where there is a reliable and unsecured mass of humanity, and I don't think anyone is bothering with that ...
I used to wheel my grandfather into games on a wheelchair... they didn't check anything, just waved you through. A wheel chair sized bomb would be easy to bring in, but you don't even have to bring it in.
We have secure ID schemes that I believe most if not all of the 9/11 attackers would have qualified to get ...
In the US we don't have mass terrorist events that any of this would prevent.
Why do we keep subjecting non-terrorists to these systems?
What are we doing this for?
- spoonjim 5y agoThat security isn’t necessarily to stop terrorism. It’s also to stop people from bringing in weapons and then using them in drunken brawls.
- duxup 5y ago>using them in drunken brawls. That's not a thing at games I've been to. Lots of drunken folks, but fights are exceptionally rare.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat is amazing reasoning. Assuming drunken brawls were a problem, instead of banning alcohol, the solution was the current TSA protocol.
- spoonjim 5y agoAlcohol makes money, outside weapons don’t. If they could get away with selling you knives in the stadium they probably would.
- Grazester 5y agoToo much money in alcohol to ban it. Due to the behaviour of people on planes now, some airline have temporarily stopped serving it but passengers could still get it at a bar at the airport or buy a bottle of alcohol at a duty free store and drink themselves stupid before boarding the plane. I dont think they can easily ban that. edit:// OP clarified this was meant for sports games.
- spamizbad 5y agoMost airline passengers would trade dry flights for pre-9/11 security screenings.
- spoonjim 5y agoI’m talking about college football games.
- rootusrootus 5y agoInstantly. Where do I sign?
- ceejayoz 5y agohttps://www.cbp.gov/travel/trusted-traveler-programs/global-entry https://www.cbp.gov/travel/trusted-traveler-programs/global-... https://www.tsa.gov/precheck https://www.tsa.gov/precheck https://www.clearme.com/ https://www.clearme.com/
- rootusrootus 5y agoI have global entry & precheck (ironically, global entry is often slower than just using their app when you arrive). It's nice, for sure, but it's not pre-9/11 security. It's close, I guess, for just the traveller. But I miss the days when family could come to the gate. Maybe airports are too busy for that anyway, now, but I can dream.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> But I miss the days when family could come to the gate. Maybe airports are too busy for that anyway, now, but I can dream. I kinda miss it too, and it's a bit of a shock seeing it happen in old movies now, but I already struggle to find seating at the gate. Even if the security concerns went away entirely in a magical world, I'd bet this restriction would stay.
- jaywalk 5y agoMost airline passengers can already trade $85 every five years for pre-9/11 security screenings. They simply choose not to.
- irrational 5y agoBut, that wasn’t even a problem pre-2001. Do you not remember what things were like pre 9/11?
- sureglymop 5y agoI think what he's mentioning has nothing to do with 9/11 though, right? He's talking about football hooligans. I only know that there are such scenes in soccer here in Europe and it can get pretty rough when they clash.
- lexapro 5y agoNot wearing a seat belt was also not a problem pre-1984.
- irrational 5y agoTell me about it. I got to lay on top of the families suitcases in the back of the station wagon on road trips. It’s so much easier to sleep like that.
- lexapro 5y agoYes, until you die in an accident that you could have survived with a seat belt.
- irrational 5y agoWhich is exactly why my everyone in my car wears their seat belts. But that doesn't change the fact that it was easier to sleep when laying down in the back of the station wagon.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> What are we doing this for? No longer high on the list of priorities for politicians, so insufficient benefit for risking being seen as the politician that wants to make life easier (regardless that this is not true) for terrorists.
- nashalo 5y ago> What are we doing this for? I think we are doing these mostly useless things in order to signal that as a society we're somewhat careful in order to reassure people. I feel our best security defense is that most people are not terrorists?
- bserge 5y agoThe goal of terrorism is to scare people into restricting their own freedoms. It has worked amazingly well so far. To any motivated anti-society organization or person, this is huge leverage. A few deaths leading to a noticeably more authoritarian state? What's not to love? It doesn't even matter if the authorities do their job and punish those responsible, the people will still choose to restrict their own freedoms and makes their lives worse for more "security".
- jdavis703 5y agoThis actually isn’t the goal of terrorism. I’ve studied terrorism and the definition is essentially non-state actors using violence for political means. Now we can go in to various conspiracies from “Bush planned 9.11 as a false flag” to “Bush ignored intelligence reports so he could launch the war on terror,” but those are mostly just unproven conspiracies unrelated to what al-Qaeda wanted.
- maybelsyrup 5y ago> non-state actors States can, have, and do engage in terrorism.
- platz 5y agoNot if the definition of terrorism I use is one of the 11 definitions that preclude that possibility.
- Dudeman112 5y agoYes, some definitions are crappy. Do we have a word for "imperialist government uses violence against people to achieve political goals"? Because "it's not terrorism because it's a state" is always gonna stink of trying to dodge the topic on a technicality.
- Sebb767 5y ago
- LanceH 5y ago> What are we doing this for? At college football games this is all done to drive up the price of concessions.
- duxup 5y agoI have my doubts that the cost of hiring that much security makes them much of anything. I didn't see anyone bringing picnics to the game ... at all even before the events.
- xscott 5y agoI suspect it's not about protecting the people (your college stadium example), and that it is about protecting the expensive airplanes. If I'm being charitable, it might also be about protecting the buildings that planes can crash into.
- ridethebike 5y agoPlanes are not that expensive
- edgriebel 5y agoLast time I checked even a relatively small 737 is ca. $100 million. You must be related to Bezos if you don't consider that expensive.
- ridethebike 5y agoCompared to lives lost $100 is not expensive at all. But sure, let's forget about morals for a second (lives lost and all that) and be very cold and cynical about the pricing. Still - reputational damage, political outcry, people suing the company/government for "failing to do even basic security checks like belts and shoes" - $100 million is nothing.
- luxuryballs 5y agoThis is why I believe the TSA wasn’t made to protect citizens it was only made to prevent airplanes from being used as projectiles against the government/military.
- dzonga 5y agojust like the police doesn't exist to serve and protect the public. but to protect private property. it's all doublespeak as george orwell would've called it.
- jdavis703 5y ago> We have secure ID schemes that I believe most if not all of the 9/11 attackers would have qualified to get ... Secure ID is designed so people on various no fly lists won’t be allowed to fly should they acquire a fake ID. How well this works in practice remains to be seen, but it’s the theory at least.
- aspaviento 5y agoMaybe it's just for discouraging people from any attempt.
- duxup 5y agoBut in the college football game example, there's no discouragement right at the gates, no security, and they don't even bother with hitting an unsecured target at the same venue.
- mrtksn 5y ago> It would be far more effective to do something at the gates dude to the density of humanity Maybe it is about shifting the blame. If something happens outside, it's the police failure but if something happens inside it is venue management failure. Anyway, I completely agree that we have given up way too much in the name of security. If it's not the terrorist, then it is "think of the children" scare and we are about to get our personal devices scanning our personal files and report us to the authorities. For now it is CSAM material but I don't see any reason why the same devices wouldn't be scanning for other stuff once the system is in place. I totally expect our devices to start checking on us for "betrayal" patterns once the conflict with China intensifies, for example. Once you become a "human resource" and nothing more in the eyes of the political structures, you will need to be managed and in 2020s the tools for it are plenty and powerful.
- hunterb123 5y agoThe new thing is "think of grandma". Say delta variant enough and you can get anyone to give up anything. Post covid is like post 9/11. This is the new normal. Vaccine passports and all.
- duxup 5y agoThinking of other people and getting a vaccine and going on with your life without much of any impact seems like a very low bar.
- hunterb123 5y agoMany reasons to not get a mRNA vaccine, natural immunity is one. Thinking that you need everyone to get a vaccine to live a normal life is a strange bar.
- duxup 5y ago>Thinking that you need everyone to get a vaccine to live a normal life is a strange bar. I don't understand what that means. What happened to thinking of other people? When I think of getting a vaccine... I just do it as a part of normal life. It doesn't change my life at all, outside of added immunity.
- wpietri 5y agoIs the primary goal of security at a college football game to stop a suicide bomber? I strongly doubt that's how they see it.
- lexapro 5y agoYeah, isn't it to prevent hooligans from bringing weapons into the stadium?
- duxup 5y agoThat's not really a problem for college football, or really any sport in the US. For whatever reason the hooligan thing isn't a system in the US.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoalcohol more like
- q1w2 5y agoIt worked in Paris a few years ago. Two suicide bombers were stopped at security and detonated their suicide vests - no other people were killed besides the terrorists.
- wpietri 5y agoI agree it may also do that. My question is whether that's the goal of people inspecting bags at college sports. When I was in college, campus security already banned a range of items at sports games. In 1989, they made national news for adding marshmallows to the list of banned objects: https://www.nytimes.com/1989/10/26/sports/michigan-to-ban-marshmallows.html https://www.nytimes.com/1989/10/26/sports/michigan-to-ban-ma... That suggests to me that college stadium security is mainly about policing mundane behavior at college stadiums, and very little to do with terrorism.
- yaris 5y ago"If someone did want to do something at such a sporting event, nothing is stopping them from doing it at the gates" - this has already happened in Russia (Volgograd, 2013). A suicide bomber blowed himself up in front of a security gate at the main train station. Between 37 and 50 injured, 16 dead as the result.
- FearlessNebula 5y agoAnd at the Brussels Airport in 2016, in the check-in hall prior to security.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bradstewart 5y agoI'll agree that most stadium security seems to be mostly theatre, but people are definitely not more spread out once inside the stadium. At least not at any large stadium I've ever been in which at least a dozen entrances with people going in over the course of several hours.
- usrusr 5y ago> If someone did want to do something at such a sporting event, nothing is stopping them from doing it at the gates where there is a reliable and unsecured mass of humanity Theres a mass of people, but few cameras. Much worse cost/benefit ratio in terms of whatever craziness terrorists would supposedly consider benefit. (feel free to spend the rest of your day thinking up silly wordplay involving "bang for the buck", I wish you were alone in this if you do)
- meragrin_ 5y ago> nothing is stopping them from doing it at the gates where there is a reliable and unsecured mass of humanity, Doing it at the gates is not going to be seen live by millions. Having it seen by the masses in real time and without warning is far more effective than having it merely reported.
- TroisM 5y ago> It would be far more effective to do something at the gates dude to the density of humanity there where there is no security Maybe the goal is to protect the people that are inside... players, managers, etc...
- javert 5y ago> What are we doing this for? The "Homeland Security" apparatus is hungry and must grow. It's about jobs, power, and money for these bureaucrats. The "Homeland Security" apparatus is the most powerful political force in America, and is more dominant than either political party. Another term for this is the police-military-industrial complex.
- chakkepolja 5y agoPolice-military-industrial complex is bad. But the liberal_arts-journalism-clickbait complex overstates it.
- aerostable_slug 5y agoRe: attacking outside security, radical Islamist terrorists did exactly that in the departures hall of Brussels Airport, 2016. They killed 17 people in a pair of suicide bombings there and injured many more, which were followed up by a similar attack on the Metro. There were enough cameras and coverage that the terrorists achieved their objective (publicity).
- adoxyz 5y agoI guess another reason for the security theater is to keep the powerful safe. If a bunch of random fans get hurt going to a concert or sporting event, it's nbd, but if someone "important" gets hurt it's a much bigger deal. Maybe a pessimistic view.
- r00fus 5y agoThere's a name for it: Security Theater [1]. "Security theater is the practice of taking security measures that are intended to provide the feeling of improved security while doing little or nothing to achieve it." Some have likened it to a jobs program that both increases the surveillance capability of the government as well as provides political creds for the representatives in those districts where airports exist, similar to the Military Industrial Complex. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_theater https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_theater
- spywaregorilla 5y agoI like those checks though. It won't stop a guy trying to do a mass killing. It will stop a guy prone to getting drunk and casually carrying a gun who might be fine cheating the system if they're not checking, but not if they are checking.