3 ms·
This has been posted before. Descartes's point is about existence in the strictest sense , not about being a social person. He means that the only certainty is
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
This has been posted before.
Descartes's point is about existence in the strictest sense , not about being a social person. He means that the only certainty is your own existence as "thinking thing".
- jfengel 5y agoBut what if that's not true? What if a "thinking thing" isn't really a meaningful concept in the absence of all of the other things? We can discuss it as an abstraction, but it may be an oversimplification that obscures rather than clarifies. For example, we often talk about thinking in terms of language. If no other beings existed, what kind of thinking would there be? Could you even think "Cogito ergo sum" if there were nobody to say it to? Human brains evolved in societies, and it may not be meaningful to study that "strictest sense" without taking that into account. Maybe some day we'll be able to study AIs or even "uploaded" brains in isolation, but we don't even know how to think about the parameters of such an experiment, much less what it would reveal. So from the point of view of a cognitive scientist (as TFA is written), it's worth considering an approach that leaves Descartes off entirely, and to consider brains in society. It's been noted for a long time that language is a matter of both speaker and hearer, rather than an idealized logical form applied to an idealized ontology.
- mytailorisrich 5y ago> But what if that's not true? Well I think that is true. I think what you're saying, and especially what the author of the article of the article is saying, tries to attack Descartes by changing the topic, a sort of strawman argument. What Descartes investigates is knowledge and the scientific method in search of demonstrable truths using "methodic doubt". What can I be sure of? Well, I can doubt everything and everything my senses tell me. But the fact that I doubt and think means that one thing is sure: I exist as a thinking entity. All what you're saying about language, interactions with others, societies, is not relevant to Descartes' point. In its conclusion the article says: > There is a Zulu phrase, ‘Umuntu ngumuntu ngabantu’, which means ‘A person is a person through other persons.’ Yes, I agree. But that has nothing to do with Descartes, so I'm puzzled as to why that would translate in a title claiming that "Descartes was wrong".
- jfengel 5y agoIt's relevant in that language constrains what you can think. (At least according to one version of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, which I don't actually hold myself, but it illustrates the point.) So if you couldn't communicate with anybody, you might not have language at all. Maybe you wouldn't be a thinking entity, at least not in the sense that you currently understand "thinking". The article is trying a different approach, one more social and ontological than epistemological. I think, being a cognitive scientist, that the author has the more epistemological approach in mind, but is expressing it in other ways. A full elaboration of this argument would involve unpacking Sapir-Whorf, and doesn't fit into a blog post. I just thought it was worth arguing. If you're going to pare your epistemology down to "Cogito", we still need to be clear on what cogitation is. There's good reason to think that language and cogitation are linked, and it's not clear that we can separate them as a thinking entity with nobody to talk to.
- mytailorisrich 5y ago> It's relevant in that language constrains what you can think. What you can think is an issue that comes after whether you think and exist at all. The article does not take a different approach. It's effectively engaging in a strawman argument (all encapsulated in the title itself). My feeling is that the author wants to show that African philosophy holds its own compared to European/Western philosophy, but unfortunately she misses the target.