2 ms·
Some associated thoughts from 2016: There's a remaining element that's not included here though, and that's the idea of connecting those questions into a coher
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Some associated thoughts from 2016:
There's a remaining element that's not included here though, and that's the idea of connecting those questions into a coherent framework. Something I'm looking at in that regard is How Superstition Won and Science Lost: Popularizing Science and Health in the United States, by John C. Burnham. (http://www.worldcat.org/title/how-superstition-won-and-science-lost-popularizing-science-and-health-in-the-united-states/oclc/14966124&referer=space_alien_cat http://www.worldcat.org/title/how-superstition-won-and-scien...) One element Burnham attacks specifically is the desystematisation of scientific communication, most especially in the popular media, where the goal "was to make the reader look at the paper and say, 'Gee whiz!'". The result:
The danger of unconnected facts outside of a systematic context was recognized early in all fields. In 1901, Stratton D. Brooks, who taught pedagogy at the University of Illinois, criticized untrained science teachers who, lacking 'the spirit of scientific investigation,' taught useless facts unrelated to the body of science. More than thirty years later, another educator was still denouncing 'giving the world facts without teaching it how to think about those facts and how to use them properly.' Nor was this phenomenon merely an aspect of bad teaching. F.C. Robinson of Bowdoin in 1905 denounced 'scraps of health knowledge ... - predigested knowledge brought on with one's predigested breakfast food,' facts that could entertain but not influence. By 1945, Carl J Potthoff of the University of Minnesota was still saying, 'Health education today emphasizes facts; its contribution otherwise to the thinking discipline appears to be fragmentary,' and in 1972 the authors of a Food and Drug Administration report found that most Americans did not have a systematic approach to health but rather used a 'rampant empiricism' based upon isolated facts and personal 'experience.' In 1947, historian of science I. Bernard Cohen was observing that specialization had broken popular science presentations into fragments: 'The average reader is not at fault for having little feeling for the life of science as a whole,' because modern popularization 'has introduced him to unconnected scientific achievements,' mostly, of course, practical. And in 1981, Leon Tractman of Purdue was complaining that he was so overcome by the facts of popularized science that he doubted their utility for anything....
https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/5bkbmg/a_day_in_the_park_on_questions_and_answers/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/5bkbmg/a_day_i...