6 ms·
> Men are failing because it is the policy not to support them. And because men need the support. I suspect that a lot fewer men needed support in, say, 1950.
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
> Men are failing because it is the policy not to support them.
And because men need the support. I suspect that a lot fewer men needed support in, say, 1950.
Why do more men need support than did in 1950? I think the first reason may be because of education. Our education system is failing in a way that it wasn't in 1950. (This may be too harsh. If, say, 10% of high school graduates went to college in 1950, and 50% do now, then that means that the top 10% then were more prepared for college than the top 50% are now. But apples-to-apples would be to ask whether the top 10% then were better prepared than the top 10% are now. I don't have a good feel for the answer to that question.)
- II2II 5y agoThe other thing add that it is okay to support men who need that support. This was exactly what the Ontario Ministry of Education was encouraging men to get into teaching a decade ago. They had data that showed boys attainment of literacy was declining and viewed more male role models as a potential solution. It is also worth noting that providing supports for men does not mean removing supports for other under represented groups.
- zepto 5y ago> And because men need the support. I suspect that a lot fewer men needed support in, say, 1950. > Why do more men need support than did in 1950? My answer is that when men were the vast majority consumers of higher education the system was built to support them. This accords with what the social justice people would say, and I think they are right about that. What they are wrong about is that men today should be denied support that other groups have today because men in the 1950s had support that other groups in the 1950s did not have.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoFair point. But my impression (only that) is that college in 1950 was much less hand-holding and "supportive" in general than it is in 2021. What there was, however, was almost certainly tuned for males (and in fact white males). I totally agree with your last paragraph.
- happythen 5y agoWhat support is not offered now that men had in the 1950's?
- zepto 5y agoMen today not should be denied support that other groups have today because men in the 1950s had support that other groups in the 1950s did not have. The original article explicitly addresses this.
- happythen 5y agoJust saying thats not answering the question, guys today have so much more, except for more severe inequality over their counterparts.
- zepto 5y agoThe question is fully answered. Men today are no less deserving of support than anyone else. They deserve the same support that other groups have today. If you read the article you’ll see that men do not have the same support that other groups have, and proposals to provide that support are rejected on the basis of history rather than present need. The desire ‘not to help white men’ is explicitly mentioned.
- happythen 5y agoyea totally changed my mind, it does sound like things just aren't fair and the other "groups" have it better while the white man "deserves" it's fair share. Should we start a group or what? Which other group should we target first to get the "support" that we need?
- zepto 5y agoYour response is dripping with sarcasm. Why do you have such hatred of white men in particular? Also, why are you making this about race? The basis of the article was about how men are not getting the support they need. Why do you keep bringing “white men” into it? All we’re taking about is recognizing that there are support services provided to women which are not provided to men, and there is no reason that men shouldn’t also need such services. These are simply facts stated in the article. What have you got against men that makes you want to deny them the same services as women? Is it your opinion that white men, or men in general are somehow less deserving than young women? Or perhaps you think young men are inherently superior to women and therefore don’t have the same needs. It’s not clear which it is. Only you can tell us.
- happythen 5y agoIt's called therapy, not blaming other people that don't look like you coming up. And yea, therapy is expensive and usually not covered by medical insurance. So vote.
- zepto 5y ago> not blaming other people that don't look like you coming up What makes you imagine anyone here is blaming people that don’t look like them for something?
- happythen 5y agoall the men on here complaining they aren't getting support while others are, definitely aren't blaming anyone, you're right, I took that too far. Seeing a lot of men write how they are super stoked women are finally getting some small advantages in academia.
- zepto 5y ago> all the men on here complaining they aren't getting support while others are, Where are these complaining men? I see people critiquing policies. I think you are making up in your head that there are men on here complaining about their situation. > definitely aren't blaming anyone, you're right, I took that too far. Your sarcasm is causing you to dishonestly represent what others are saying. > Seeing a lot of men write how they are super stoked women are finally getting some small advantages in academia. They aren’t getting a small advantage. The advantage is huge across the entire educational spectrum now. Nobody should be celebrating that any more than we should have been celebrating men having an advantage in the past. The goal is for our systems to support everyone. Not to punish present day people based on arbitrary characteristics they share with people in the past.
- happythen 5y agoyour right, sarcasm is a tool of the devil and it's so unauthentic, it's like lying but with an even more evil purpose. You are complaining, right now, about how now women get a situational advantage. And we shouldn't celebrate that they are better represented in academia! No mas zepto, at this point you just need to get out in the world and see what life is like for others, quit worrying about how underprivileged you are.