4 ms·
While you can make that argument today, Netflix as a company is 24 years old. It got to its current position not by spending $15B/yr on original content (which
by paxys 5y ago
While you can make that argument today, Netflix as a company is 24 years old. It got to its current position not by spending $15B/yr on original content (which it can afford to do now) but purely based on a superior and novel tech experience for its users.
Of course eventually all discussions of this nature devolve into the intricate definition of "tech company", and in the absence of one that is agreed upon, bringing this whole thing up is pointless.
- tnzk 5y agoDefinitely. The title of OP should be 'Netflix is no longer a tech company' or so.
- saalweachter 5y agoEh, as a user Netflix original content is a large part of why I still have a subscription. I used Netflix back when it was mailing me DVDs, and loved the online streaming back in the halcyon days when it seemed like they had everything. Then came the dark days when content owners began pulling their IP from Netflix and scattering it all over the internet behind a dozen different options that offered them more money or control, and Netflix was a barren wasteland without anything that caught my eye; my queue was a variety of B-tier series that I tried a few episodes of and gave up on. So I canceled my subscription, for several years. It didn't matter what their UX or uptime was or how smooth their video codecs, they didn't have enough content I wanted to watch. Then I came back for the original content -- I forget which series first made me sign back up; House of Cards? -- and while I watch licensed content on Netflix from time to time, at least half of what I watch is produced by Netflix.
- musingsole 5y ago> It didn't matter what their UX or uptime was or how smooth their video codecs, they didn't have enough content I wanted to watch. Netflix has developed a novel data system (as evidenced by papermill) that is likely responsible for countless decisions that manifested the content which brought you back. I don't know first hand but I suspect data is integrated into their everyday processes in ways most companies can't even dream of. Does that make them a technology company again?
- saalweachter 5y agoAnd Disney/Pixar is constantly pushing the bleeding edge of computer animation and CGI special effects. Is Disney a technology company?
- mattkrause 5y agoDisney's research divisions do a lot of really cool stuff: - https://studios.disneyresearch.com/publications/ https://studios.disneyresearch.com/publications/ - https://la.disneyresearch.com/publication/ https://la.disneyresearch.com/publication/
- makeitdouble 5y agoAs much as I am not a fan of Disney, I think they are. Even outside of movies they have significant care to innovate and push the boundaries, for instance in theme park animatronics or toys in general.
- asdff 5y agoThis is a little bit hyperbole don't you think? I think companies with means these days just invest in this sort of technology because that's what you do in business now. Target is a department store but I wouldn't be surprised to learn they are hiring pure machine learning researchers too and doing remarkable things with data as well, same goes for any large company. 60 years ago you had large companies operating complex switchboards in their offices but you would never call these businesses telephone companies even though they operated their own internal telephone network. That sort of technology was just a tool of the trade, just like data science is now for large companies. I wouldn't call netflix a technology company when literally every large video production company is investing in the same things and trying to hire the same sort of talent, and you wouldn't call MGM or warner brothers a technology company either.
- musingsole 5y agoIs Coca-Cola a sugary drinks company, a logistics company, or a technology company producing hardware, software, chemical engineering processes and countless other disciplines to enable international scale methods and logistics employed in delivering various liquids and other goods all over the globe?
- lmkg 5y agoI was going to say something similar. It's inarguable that they were a tech company, when they pioneered streaming delivery for existing video content. Their tech platform was their primary differentiator to competitors for a number of years. Whether they are currently a tech company is a bit fuzzier. Certainly they new have content as an additional differentiator, and the margin of their tech advantage has narrowed.
- drewg123 5y agoI think we have a large advantage in the CDN space, both in integration and efficiency. In terms of efficiency, we've been serving at 100Gb/s (mostly TLS encrypted) from single socket servers since 2017, and are moving towards 400Gb/s today. How many other companies can say that? I'm talking about the push to 400Gb/s at EuroBSDCon online, a week from Sunday..
- treis 5y agoBut that mostly doesn't matter. The consumer doesn't care if their movies are coming from a server handling 10Gb/s or 100 Gb/s or 400 Gb/s. There's cost savings there, but I imagine that content costs dwarf delivery costs at this point. There is some technology component where the UI, resposiveness, reliability, and so on impact the user experience. But still content is king there. The HBO apps suck and their streaming is less reliable than others but they've got the content I wanna watch so I put up with it.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> purely based on a superior and novel tech experience for its users. I don't think this is accurate - the main value proposition of Netflix seems to have always been "streaming site with lots of mainstream content, that is also legal". I.e. it's the streaming deals they've made that mattered, not delivery tech or their web player.
- barbecue_sauce 5y agoPretty sure he's talking about the OG Netflix DVD-by-mail request-by-web model.
- filmgirlcw 5y agoNo. For the first decade plus of its existence, Netflix was a DVD by mail rental service and there, its technology was a key differentiator. You paid a subscription depending on how many DVDs you wanted to have out at a time, Netflix mailed them to you in red envelopes, and you mailed them back in the same envelope. The ingenious part was that there was a website where you entered in all of the DVDs you wanted and Netflix would mail them to you as they either became available or in order of priority (the original Netflix queue). Yes, you could be pedantic and call a lot of that logistics, but the lack of physical stores, the website, the queue and rating and recommendation system (the Netflix recommendation algorithm was a huge part of its appeal, even after the streaming stuff, until Netflix got sued for accidentally outing someone with the algo), were all tech. Netflix has ALWAYS been a hybrid tech and content company. Always. But it started out very much more on disrupting the video store model the same way Amazon disrupted brick and mortar bookstores.
- teawrecks 5y agoThen all companies are tech companies. They all aim to come up with a product that's better than the last, and they almost never use old tech to do it.
- filmgirlcw 5y agoWell, yes. In a certain way, everything is tech. Tech != computers/engineers/algorithms/robots/HAl/whatever. But even in the popular understanding of what a tech company is, Netflix more than many others DOES have historical and current tech bonafides. 25 years ago during dot com mania, there wasn’t a lot of hand-wringing about whether WebVan or Pets.com or Amazon or whatever were tech companies. It was accepted that e-commerce WAS tech, even if it was different than DEC/Compaq/HP or Sun or Microsoft or Apple or whatever. And Netflix operated from a website, used technology for its logistic and delivery system (much like other e-commerce systems)and had a recommendation algorithm (that they had a contest to improve, because they saw that good recommendations reduced churn) and a focus on UX to keep the product good. It took them more than a decade, but the goal of delivering video via the Internet was always there. Roku, which in its original incarnation was simply a Netflix streaming box, was originally ideated and developed at Netflix before the company decided it didn’t want to be in the hardware business and so the head of the project and the engineers left to make Roku. Netflix has done as much work as any single company except perhaps YouTube to optimize and pioneer how to effectively serve large swaths of video to users across the globe. The problem with Ben Evans’ piece is that he misunderstands that Netflix has always been a tech and a content company. Even when it was a rental company with more tech and no original content, the recommendation algorithm and the dedication to buyers and curators who would make the decisions about what DVDs were purchased (eventually customer signals played into this too) always had a very strong content focus in the product. That’s the reason Netflix works. It was the first media company to really innately understand both tech and content. Disney and HBO (WarnerMedia, whatever) have great tech stacks too (especially Disney), but Netflix was the first and is still the most successful.
- pmoleri 5y agoI disagree, I think getting the license to stream the content is a much more difficult problem than the technology to stream it.
- robertlagrant 5y agoOnly once each of the thousands of impossible problems that need solving in order to stream reliably have been solved. That's the problem with software. It solves problems so well they stay solved, and only constructed problems such as IP ownership remain.
- eslaught 5y agoPerhaps Netflix has shifted. In the beginning, I think you could have made a good argument that technology was their moat, but I don't think you can say so today. Today, their best attempt at a moat is content, and it's a poor one at best since they can only make so much original content and it's not as if they can do so in a way that is inaccessible to other services.
- robertlagrant 5y agoContent for them seems a desperate attempt at countering deep content firms' moats, who can now build streaming services copycatting Netflix.
- sfink 5y agoRight. It started as a shipping service company that specialized exclusively in DVDs.
- omegalulw 5y ago> but purely based on a superior and novel tech experience for its users. I mean they were the pioneers in offering tv and movies via streaming. The tech is really not that dramatic. You can think of streaming tech in three parts: video quality, recommendations and UI. Arguably video quality is the most important, but other platforms have already offer similar/better quality (albeit a lil more data). Their recommendations and UI are better than others but I honestly don't care about these two as they are still not good enough for me to discover content I would want to watch, for that I still have to go to reddit/curated articles. So I would say Netflix's contribution was more in pioneering tv streaming as opposed to tech. They are now competing mostly in terms of their originals, so I would label them more like Disney/HBO rather than tech.