3 ms·
Social Security is not funded by the government, it's funded by payroll taxes. Saying that Social Security loaning money to the government is meaningless is lik
by pessimizer 5y ago
Social Security is not funded by the government, it's funded by payroll taxes. Saying that Social Security loaning money to the government is meaningless is like saying that you loaning money to your brother-in-law is meaningless because you both have accounts at the same bank.
Debt is debt.
- caturopath 5y ago> Social Security is not funded by the government, it's funded by payroll taxes This fictional accounting is a silly marketting gimmick, not a meaningful distinction. It's a government program just like all other forms of welfare. Do you think that there were decades when lots of folks were contributing and no one was collecting?
- NoSorryCannot 5y agoUh, if accounting is a fiction, well, I'm not going to say there isn't a kernel of truth to that, but it doesn't help us answer the question of who has debt responsibilities to whom; the entire enterprise is predicated axiomatically on "accounting fictions".
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Social Security is not funded by the government, it's funded by payroll taxes. If it is funded by taxes, it is funded by government. You could argue that the social security trust funds are loaning money to the general fund, but that’s like saying your savings account and money market account are loaning money to your checking account.
- caturopath 5y agoSocial Security is a government program like any other. The delineation of tax types is just branding to make people like it more, it isn't economically meaningful. When the payroll tax is higher than the SS spend, the government just spends the money. (These bonds are IOUs for all the times they do that.) It's like saying that it's meaningless for you to loan yourself money, because it is (except when there is some other, external reason that it carries meaning, not by rules you made yourself.) We constantly ignore these internal self-debts for people and for companies. https://www.cbpp.org/research/recommendation-that-presidents-fiscal-commission-focus-on-gross-debt-is-misguided https://www.cbpp.org/research/recommendation-that-presidents... notes > Most economists agree that the debt held by the public is what really affects the economy. As the Congressional Budget Office stated in its June 2009 report on the long-term budget outlook, “Long-term projections of federal debt held by the public, measured relative to the size of the economy, provide useful yardsticks for assessing the sustainability of fiscal policies.” In contrast, “gross debt . . . is not useful for assessing how the Treasury’s operations affect the economy.”