10 ms·
>"we'll never log your IPs" is something that no company can hold. Four words: The Intercept, Secure Drop. A one-way mail (content submission) system that runs
by dexen 5y ago
>"we'll never log your IPs" is something that no company can hold.
Four words: The Intercept, Secure Drop. A one-way mail (content submission) system that runs exclusively on Tor, and thus can't be supboenated for users' IP address.
While I get your premise due to concerns of law, I think it is entirely feasible - and hinges on execution, marketing ability. We already have IP-hiding technology, whether Tor or Freenet or other such. The concern is "are we good enough yet to make it a sustainable business?"
For sake of example: if a hypothetical competitor to ProtonMail was to offer sign-up and email access only over Tor protocol, it would effectively be safe from police's demands to start logging IPs - thanks to technical measures. The actual difficulty is in the business side: getting enough paying customers to install & enable relevant browser or browser plugin.
Granted, the police could try to force the hypothetical competitor to install malicious JavaScript that would try to gather & leak users' IP address or other identifying information through other means, but that's solvable in the longer run just as well.
- dhimes 5y agoI also have to wonder if the market size for this a truly anonymous email truly is. Who would go out of their way to pay for more expensive email that was untraceable? How many reporters? How many "freedom fighters"? How many large-scale criminal organizations? And does the very fact of using it bring unwanted attention?
- dexen 5y agoExcellent contention, and I don't have a ready-made answer yet. Curiously enough, we've seen anonymous services succeed for results unrelated to privacy-from-government: places like Omegle & ChatRoulette use anonymity for fun; places like 4chan use anonymity both for fun and also to avoid certain problems common to name-posting. Anonymity has long been a viable alternative put to good use in literature, arts, and entertainment. Perhaps the proper marketing would be along those lines?
- staplers 5y agoAt this point, creating an entirely new protocol would be easier. Something like Bitmessage.