3 ms·
I wonder how many people who throw accusations of "closet X" and "stealth Y" so easily are, in fact, themselves closet X and stealth Y and generalize about othe
by inglor_cz 5y ago
I wonder how many people who throw accusations of "closet X" and "stealth Y" so easily are, in fact, themselves closet X and stealth Y and generalize about other people based on their own carefully hidden prejudices.
- baybal2 5y agoI'm always public about my convictions, sometime too public according to the moderators of HN.
- inglor_cz 5y agoWell, to be honest, claiming that people who say A do in fact mean B, is more of an attempt at mind reading of others than just another conviction. This is frowned upon, because there is no bottom to this race downwards. Anyone can accuse anyone else of being a horrible, rotten human being who just puts up a tolerable facade.
- imbnwa 5y ago> Anyone can accuse anyone else of being a horrible, rotten human being who just puts up a tolerable facade. You say this as if human beings are entirely unfamiliar with the use of facades in everyday life (need I mention most women's familarity with "the nice guy"), more so in those domains where power and position are at stake.
- inglor_cz 5y agoNo, I wanted to say that we should apply some threshold of evidence before making accusations like this, and we shouldn't apply them onto large groups of people.
- dennis_jeeves 5y agoThis is true, very true, People often project their own prejudice by labeling/accusing others of the same prejudices. Nothing much can be done about these people other than avoiding dealing with them on a personal front.
- notSupplied 5y agoReminds me of Conflict vs Mistake theory. Mistake theorists worry about whether an idea is true. Conflict theorists worry about whether an idea is useful their enemies. Shifting the argument to "bad faith", "closet X", "stealth Y" is exactly that: It says nothing about whether something true, only that "it helps the bad guys."