4 ms·
> There is something self-defeating about large tech companies. If you remove "tech" from this sentence I think it's still true, and it points you towards the
by nicoburns 5y ago
> There is something self-defeating about large tech companies.
If you remove "tech" from this sentence I think it's still true, and it points you towards the solution: bias the economy towards small companies (for example, via progressive corporation tax). There's a bit of nuance here: I think a lot of the problem is with public companies. So we could probably do a lot by reforming the public ownership system.
- WJW 5y agoThere are definitely benefits to having large companies as well, though. Economies of scale are a real thing for one, and especially in the semiconductor industry the price of modern production facilities (>20 bn per fab) is well outside the reach of any company you could still call "small".
- nicoburns 5y agoThere are, but even in these cases there are economic downsides: notably with semi-conductors, risk if any of these big companies fail. I think that if the benefit of scale is so great, then you should be able to prove it by withstanding the higher tax burden.
- GDC7 5y agoIt's not even companies. It's people! As they progress they become more risk averse and are terrified by the idea of losing their wealth. That's why we have entire sectors of the economy focused on wealth preservation without volatility. These people want a stable and steady climb upwards. I think it's because there is an alarming lack of arrogance and self-confidence in the world. It's visible in every possible datapoint . People say those things are bad, but in reality they keep the system honest. The best way to redistribute wealth is wealthy individuals overplaying their hand. It doesn't ever happen, there is something deeply wrong in Bill Gates being at the top of the Forbes rich list for 30 years. His brain should have adapted to the new normal and compelled him to risk his whole fortune in the hope of making even more money, maybe becoming the first trillionarie. That's how wealth is redistributed; rich people becoming greedy and overplaying their hand. It doesn't happen, rich people are happy being at the top and they are not ambitious enough to reach for the impossible milestones. The only nut out there who does it is Musk but his wealth is not real yet, it's paper wealth. We'll see how Bezos decides to go about it.
- nicoburns 5y ago> His brain should have adapted to the new normal and compelled him to risk his whole fortune in the hope of making even more money Why do you think this should happen? That doesn't sound very rational to me. If you have more than you could possibly ever need then why would you choose to risk that? This is one reason why we should never reward people with these ridiculous levels of wealth in the first place. > The best way to redistribute wealth is wealthy individuals overplaying their hand. This sounds like a very wasteful and unreliable way to redistribute wealth to me. Unreliable because as you say it often doesn't happen. Wasteful because if it does happen it involves wasting enormous amounts of resources on a failed project. IMO the best way to redistribute wealth is to not allow people to become as ridiculously wealthy as they are in the first place.
- GDC7 5y ago> If you have more than you could possibly ever need then why would you choose to risk that? Because you don't simply do it for the stuff. You do it for the brain juices which are released when you win. Bill Gates biggest wins happened in the late 80s and 90s. His brain should compel him to do better than that to release those elusive juices once again. The only way to do so is having even bigger wins than the ones in the 80s and 90s > Failed project The entrepreneur's failed project is the worker dream job where you get paid for doing nothing. Kinda like the influencers hired by Bloomberg in his 2020 campaign. Nobody was checking if they were really doing the job and they just pocketed the money.
- nicoburns 5y ago> Because you don't simply do it for the stuff. You do it for the brain juices which are released when you win. Well sure, but those motivations exist regardless of any financial rewards. We are talking here about the additional effect of financial incentives. IMO the possibility of making say $1m or $10m is pretty motivating if you don't have much. But once you reach say $1B, financial incentives are unlikely to be as relevant to you. You're made for life, why should you do anything you don't want to do. > the worker dream job where you get paid for doing nothing. I think most workers would prefer to be paid to something useful/meaningful, unless they can literally go and do something completely different with no restrictions. But is rarely how billionaire's failed projects go. They usually involve a lot of people working very hard to no end.