3 ms·
The author of this article seems to be trying to confuse things: Membership in this elite group is likely to come from being involved in some aspect of the fin
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
The author of this article seems to be trying to confuse things:
Membership in this elite group is likely to come from being involved in some aspect of the financial services or banking industry, real estate development involved with those industries, or government contracting.
What does "involved in some aspect" mean?
...built a small company and was acquired with stock from a multi-national. Stock is often called a "paper" asset...CEO of a medium-cap tech company...another was able to amass $12M after taxes by her early thirties from stock options as a high level programmer in a successful IT company.
- noahth 15y agoI agree that those examples are not great at conveying the main point he's trying to make, but let's consider for a moment that the top .1% evaluates to a larger number than 5. Maybe he was calling out notable exceptions, or maybe it's just a poorly edited piece of writing.
- neuroelectronic 15y agoHe was calling out notable exceptions... | but it's infrequent to meet one whose wealth wasn't acquired through direct or indirect participation in the financial and banking industries.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoI don't think he was calling out exceptions. The paragraph intersperses people working in finance (or their ex-wives) with people not working in finance and draws no distinction between them. "One client runs a division of a major international investment bank..." In fact, one particular sentence lists both financial wealth and non-financial wealth: "Another client with a net worth in the $10M range is the ex-wife of a managing director of a major investment bank, while another was able to amass $12M after taxes by her early thirties from stock options as a high level programmer in a successful IT company." But maybe noahth is right, and the article is just poorly edited.
- neuroelectronic 15y agoI think you're just confused.
- turar 15y ago+1. A lot of his examples have nothing to do with financial services.
- mdonahoe 15y agoAll of the people in the examples made money as salaried financial services employees or through stock. So for example, the programmer didn't make her money from selling her programming products; she sold her stock, a financial instrument.
- goblgobl 15y agoShe sold her stock, which represented ownership of a business. If Mark Zuckerberg sold all his "stock" in Facebook, that doesn't mean he made his money from the financial services industry. The majority of wealthy people are wealthy by equity (ownership of a business), not from annual income. If the author used traders as an example of people making money on stocks, that would be an argument more inline with his thesis. The way he defines being involved with the finance sector, of course the majority of wealthy people (business owners) will have touched the financial services industry - the same way the average joe a touches retail bank.
- kds 15y agoThe retail bank in no way makes Joe Average far richer than he already is by his own efforts. And I don't think those Russian billionaires invested in Facebook just because they were yawning at the thought of depositing the money in a bank and the boring routine of such a transaction. They all expect huge capital gains and the pump-and-dump institutional machinery of Wall Street is the instrumental system for this.
- goblgobl 15y agoMy point was the author's claim that the top of the top 1% is "involved in the financial services industry" is meaningless because of how he defines it. The only people who don't fit his description would be salaried employees. To address your points - you're ignoring the difference in financial goals and economies of scale. Joe is an employee. So his goal is to preserve the capital he earns, which is a service the retail bank offers. He earns a paltry interest on his money because 1. the bank lends his cash out very conservatively, and 2. he's not paying for the service of having it actively managed by a professional. Rich people can not only afford professional money management, but very wealthy ones typical have access to higher quality investment vehicles than less wealthy rich. And since they have more capital (that they don't need) than Joe does, they tend to tolerate more risks. They also tend to get the rewards of that risk when its professionally managed. At that scale of money, investment can have positive externalities. The capital invested in Facebook, Google, Apple, etc directly helped create jobs and expand the technology sector. Joe's money did comparatively little. Both are rewarded for their proportional economic impact. Capital gains is an incentive to keep rich people from parking their cash at a retail bank. Whether it works 100% effectively is definitely up for debate. But the general idea is that their cash can be deployed in a way that not only makes the rich richer, but the rest of society as well.