3 ms·
> However, individuals do not necessarily inherit intelligence from their parents' genes. Do you have an alternative explanation for the results of twin studie
by concordDance 5y ago
> However, individuals do not necessarily inherit intelligence from their parents' genes.
Do you have an alternative explanation for the results of twin studies on IQ then? It's also not just IQ, so many things very strongly correlate between identical twins.
> Seriously, who could think that you could build a lineage of "gifted persons" solely by genetically selecting the parents among the population of "gifted persons"?
Does natural selection only work on non-humans then?
- slfnflctd 5y agoOne could argue that we've decoupled ourselves from natural selection in significant ways by moving toward more egalitarian societies where huge numbers of people who would've been shut out in our more brutal past aren't shut out any longer. Non-humans don't have anything comparable in terms of scale. Alternatively, it could be viewed as more of a reshuffling, where selection will still take place in the long run but with very different pressures. The way I see it, none of us asked to be born, so if we really are trying to be 'fair', everyone should be granted a base level of material support regardless of their ability to contribute. I also think all of us would be much better off we collectively valued happiness more than material wealth. There is definitely a place for incentives, but when those come with the baggage of class warfare, past a certain point they become more destructive than constructive on aggregate.