2 ms·
I think we should also be clear that the proof systems do distribute control differently. POW requires large investments and knowledge (to create a mining infr
by godelski 5y ago
I think we should also be clear that the proof systems do distribute control differently.
POW requires large investments and knowledge (to create a mining infrastructure). POS is a lot easier for people to get involved. Even though the wealthy can just invest more in POS systems there is still a more level playing field as they do not need the logistics of building mining factories and all that. Any wealthy person can simply invest. This dynamic creates the potential for a more distributed network than the POS system, although it still is biased towards the wealthy class. I'd say that this is still more fair (far from being fully fair) than Chia's system where you need hardware and technical knowhow. You're essentially making the space more competitive. Then you have PiCoin's "Proof of click" where you're just proving you can click a button every 24 hours. Wealthy still get control as they can get people to be the "sub-miners" (earning team/pyramid scheme) that normal people can't achieve. Though this is fairly easy to emulate. This still allows the wealthy to just get wealthier.
I think there is still a long way to go to determine the most fair system, but just because there is some consolidation doesn't mean that the systems are equally exploitable by a wealthy class. Ether2 is more decentralized than BitCoin, although there is a fair amount of consolidation. I doubt we will end up with a fully decentralized system (by any proof system) but the question is rather how do we make a proof system that has sufficient competition that it becomes difficult for a single entity to take control? POS is better than POW in this respect and we should note that. But we do need something better than POS.
The article does not make these distinctions and does undermine the questions within the cryptocurrency communities. It is a difficult problem to solve but we do need to be clear that the different proof systems aren't equally centralized. There's probably no way to prevent the wealthy from continuing to get wealthier from these systems, but the question is if a blockchain can become sufficiently decentralized that meaningful collusion will be near impossible to make. We are seeing steps in that direction.