7 ms·
Any government with the ability to print its own currency can always pay a debt denominated in its own currency. The only question is whether or not the curren
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
Any government with the ability to print its own currency can always pay a debt denominated in its own currency.
The only question is whether or not the currency can retain its ability to procure labor and materials.
I have no qualms about getting the numbers I am owed from social security deposited into my account. I do wonder how much I will be able to buy with it though.
- umvi 5y agoYeah let's just print trillion dollar bills to pay off the debt. Zimbabwe had trillion dollar bills if I remember correctly.
- alangibson 5y agoGoogle Modern Monetary Theory. The jist is that printing money is only inflationary when the nations productive capacity is fully utilized.
- blowski 5y agoMMT does say that, but MMT is far from being widely accepted as correct.
- alangibson 5y agoOK. No theory is widely accepted before it is.
- blowski 5y agoThat doesn’t mean “all theories are eventually correct”.
- alangibson 5y agoNo it doesn't. I was just pointing out that you weren't really saying anything in your comment.
- CraigJPerry 5y agoOf the 5 tennets of MMT, only 1 is disputed by mainstream economics i think? As i understand it, more or less everyone (excluding fringe groups) agrees that: 1. All money is created by the state or other banks acting under state licence 2. Money only has value because the government promises to back it 3. because taxes must be paid in government-issued money 4. Therefore government spending comes before taxation The bone of contention as i understand it is the 5th tennet: 5. Government deficits are necessary and good because without them the means to make settlement would not exist in our economy As i understand the argument, it boils down to a disagreement about whether public investment can crowd out private. EDIT: points from https://www.google.com/amp/s/criticalfinance.org/2019/02/06/misunderstanding-mmt/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/criticalfinance.org/2019/02/06/...
- alangibson 5y ago5 is really only debated by academics. I think the actions of policy makers prove they think it's true. Does anyone remember the debate during the Clinton years over whether or not they should start paying back government debt given a surplus?
- stephen_g 5y agoItem 5 is theoretically true if you assume accounting rules hold. The sectoral balances formula (derived from the definition of GDP) doesn't hold otherwise. The only way for the economy to grow if the Government is running surpluses is with increasing private debt (so not really "paying down" anything but just transferring debt from one sector of the economy to another), and/or with a big enough trade surplus to cancel out the other sectors.
- dllthomas 5y agoI was under the impression that 2 is manifestly false (unless I'm a very weak sense) given currencies in use that retained some value after the issuing state fell.
- alangibson 5y ago
- godelski 5y agoOne interesting thing about this is that the effect of printing money (how it influences inflation) highly depends on perception. Radio Lab talked about this in a recent episode[0]. This has been a measured effect too and so it is interesting that fearing inflation can be a self fulfilling prophesy. [0] https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/more-money-less-problems https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/more-...
- btilly 5y agoThe best example of how perception matters was how the careful introduction of the Brazilian real ended hyperinflation merely by creating a perception that it wouldn't inflate. (It was pegged to the old currency at a rate that inflated at the same rate that the old currency did. All stores had to post prices in both old and real. After people were used to seeing real standing still, Brazil started printing them and continued indexing them at inflating rates to the old. And the price stayed constant as the old currency was replaced by the new.
- ardit33 5y agoMMT is a junk theory created by silver spooned academics with no real life experience. It has not been proven in practice, or when something close to it is practices it does lead to inflation or devaluation of the country’s currency (Think Argentina, Turkey and today Lebanon). When communism fell, I remember how the west promoted the ‘shock therapy’ to former communist countries, which was devastating to them. Another junk science that lead to a ‘lost decade’ and misery in eastern countries. It was a ‘rip the Bandaid’ type of approach, which failed as it didn’t account that some countries needed time to adjust to the new capital system and it led to the closure of many lines of production that were actually profitable, as it was a ‘hard reset’ Be very wary when someone peddles a new ‘theory’ which is unproved, as a magical cure. Communism was one of them as well.
- alangibson 5y agoI'm gonna guess you know much about the history of MMT, because it was created as a description of how money works in the US by a guy that spent his career on a trading desk.
- criddell 5y agoIf it isn’t shrewd application of MMT, then what explains Japans economy?
- toomanydoubts 5y agoMMT is just something the ones in control of the printing press made up to convince gullible people that they're not being outright robbed by quantitative easing.
- alangibson 5y agoFactually incorrect. Mosler spent most of his career in a hedge fund. MMT was a description of how he thought money actually worked in the modern age.
- dv_dt 5y agoMost MMT economists I follow on the topic would say MMT is independent of QE as a policy. But also as an outlay of currency, QE is one of the least effective uses to support or generate productive capacity.
- alangibson 5y agoMMT people tend to support major direct spending to people on the bottom, not things like QE
- stephen_g 5y agoYeah, no - basically all MMT economists think QE is a bad policy.
- trts 5y agoDoes this mean I don’t need to pay taxes until the productive capacity is at 100%, because we can print it? How do we know when we’re getting close to full utilization
- alangibson 5y agoMMT says that taxes exist primarily to create demand for a currency. The government doesn't need you to give it money because it is the source of money. You'll know the economy is neat 100% because inflation will kick in.
- trts 5y agobut there has always been inflation?
- alangibson 5y agoWhen the productive capacity is at a high level of utilization, yes. There hasn't been much inflation in the West for years now. Also, deflation.
- gghhzzgghhzz 5y agoTaxes are required to give the currency value, to counter inequality and produce a stable society, to take money out of unproductive or overheating parts of the economy, and to discourage harmful (to individuals or society) behaviour.
- alangibson 5y agoThat's a pretty good rundown of MMTs thinking. The government spends money into existence. When inflation starts to tick up, tax the money back out of existence.
- jyounker 5y agoZimbabwe's debts were not held in its own currency.
- xcdfgvd 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_stroke https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_stroke
- addicted 5y agoThat’s not why Zimbabwe’s economy and currency collapsed. Zimbabwe’s economy and currency collapsed because the government stole productive assets and gave them to people who did not know how to do anything with them, basically destroying the productive capacity of the nation within a few weeks.
- TMWNN 5y ago>Zimbabwe’s economy and currency collapsed because the government stole productive assets and gave them to people who did not know how to do anything with them, basically destroying the productive capacity of the nation within a few weeks. Recent history of Zimbabwe (<http://imgur.com/a/VdQdD http://imgur.com/a/VdQdD>)
- pjc50 5y agoThe important thing about inflation is to realize you can't print foreign money. So if your trade + investment balance remains favourable, it's not a problem. If there's a major flight of investors (to where?), capital, or a thing you must import at any price (usually oil), then inflation kicks in even without money printing. The US need not worry about inflation until a bigger more stable economy comes along, which is a long way off.
- OnlineGladiator 5y ago> The US need not worry about inflation until a bigger more stable economy comes along, which is a long way off. You raised a good point about inflation not necessarily being tied to printing money, but you ignored the fact that if you print more money (without an obvious productive place for it to go) then you simply increase supply without increasing demand which causes inflation. It's happening right now in the US by just about every metric, and there is good reason to believe it is about to go up a lot more. So no, the US not only is currently experiencing inflation like it has not seen for decades but there is likely to be a lot more in the near future. The Fed is printing money like crazy (I believe we've printed approximately 30% of our total money supply in the past ~2 years, so in ~2 years we've printed approximately half as much money as we did in the previous ~200 years) which deflates the value of our currency. I actually rounded all the numbers down to make it seem less problematic than it is - I encourage you to check the data for yourself.
- alangibson 5y agoThe Fed has been printing money like crazy for over a decade. Prices are rising due to supply chain breakdowns.
- ubercow13 5y ago>I believe we've printed approximately 30% of our total money supply in the past ~2 years Doesn't that money start disappearing as soon as the QE stops?
- dv_dt 5y agoMany people including the Fed chair as well as hedge funds like Bridgewater, do not believe the current inflation is fundamentally due to issue of currency. They believe it has to do with supply side shocks driven by covid and climate events worldwide.
- gitfan86 5y agoThis is exactly what has happened during the pandemic. In 2015 if you paid $15/hour for entry level physical work you would get a lot of applications with some high quality applicants. In 2021 you need to remove the weed drug testing provision and then hope that you will get applicants. Printing 3T dollars and handing out 3k/month to everyone has caused the cost of labor to double or triple in some areas. In other words the way out of the social security insolvency is to reduce the quality of labor a dollar buys. In 2040 you should expect to get 4k/month from social security and for that to cover your food and housing, but hiring a person to replace your gutters will cost $90/hour
- jimbob45 5y agoDo you have data to back up mass drug test failing? The general consensus is that you have to be both outstandingly stupid and an actual addict to fail the well-telegraphed drug tests at most minimum wage places.
- nostromo 5y agoAmazon dropped drug testing for delivery drivers. Maybe they’re just feeling kind. More likely: they’re having trouble finding people to become delivery drivers. https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/operations/update-on-our-vision-to-be-earths-best-employer-and-earths-safest-place-to-work https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/operations/update-on-our-vi...
- lotsofpulp 5y agoAmazon does not employ delivery drivers. They recently suggested to the delivery companies they pay to deliver packages to homes not drug test in order to find drivers. I assume the drivers Amazon employs are actual truck drivers under the purview of the Department of Transportion, and are probably still drug tested to satisfy whatever federal requirements they have to satisfy. > We will no longer include marijuana in our comprehensive drug screening program for any positions not regulated by the Department of Transportation, and will instead treat it the same as alcohol use.
- msandford 5y agoRight exactly. I fully expect to pay in enough purchasing power for a house or two and to get out enough purchasing power for a car or two.
- roenxi 5y agoIn what world is a currency crisis a better outcome than people being honest about what is happening and either defaulting or raising taxes? Sovereign countries that go down the road of emergency devaluation are routinely found at the start of the worst stories. It shows that not only can't a country pay its bills, it also doesn't have the political fibre to engage with its problems.
- hakfoo 5y agoWhy are those the only options? Nationalization is also a potential and underrated part of the toolbox. A nationalized-health-care system could be a huge lever on inflation. On a basic level, it would enjoy near or full monopsony status on many products and labour categories, so it would be easy to say "our reimbursement rates rise 2% per annum, and if you want to sell ANY product, you'll take it and like it." An even more aggressive process could take medical education and supply production directly under a state umbrella, further reducing market pressure for ever-growing margins. Similarly, a "free state universities for all" program could come with strict restrictions on program costs to clamp down on spiraling costs. Other forms of state intervention-- subsidized goods, for example, or even WWII-style ration books-- could help to mitigate the negative consumer-facing effects of inflation. You might have to pay $100 per kilo of ground beef on the open market, but if we had a functional ration system, everyone still gets sufficient coupons to have a hamburger once or twice a week. If the only things you need "dollars" for are luxury nonsubsidized/nonrationed goods, then the dollar can crash and burn every few decades with minimal quality-of-life impact.
- cherrycherry98 5y agoWon't these new services require rather significant increases in taxes? Not to mention government takeover of industry to impose price fixing and rationing raises some red flags for me.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Won't these new services require rather significant increases in taxes? No, because there are no new services, just nationalization of services people are already paying for, and removing to the extent the industry has profits (or surplus revenues in the nonprofit components), nationalization would provide free revenue in first-order effect.
- manquer 5y agoThe inflation has already happened, the price of daily commodities has not changed. You will still be able to buy a carton of milk at same prices. However the price of assets like blue chip stock or a house has increased massively, we cannot really afford them anymore. Today there is no way make back principal after even 30 years with returns/dividend on most blue chip stock or rent on a house you buy/invest in. The returns are mostly based on the asset appreciating even more. This wealth inflation has resulted in being priced out of housing or generate retirement savings etc and the wealth inequality has widened so much already.