3 ms·
The need in the California "Duck Curve" is between 5pm and 10pm, when the sun is setting and solar output is dropping. Homes are still hot, and empirically spea
by dragontamer 5y ago
The need in the California "Duck Curve" is between 5pm and 10pm, when the sun is setting and solar output is dropping. Homes are still hot, and empirically speaking, everyone is still using their air conditioning units as the heat of the day is still all around the environment.
No matter how many panels you add, you won't add any electricity at 7pm / 8pm (depending on time of year) because the sun has already set. There's still substantial demand for electricity.
This means to solve the 7pm / 8pm duck curve, you need to build natural gas peaker plants, or figure out a storage methodology.
That's it. Otherwise you get brownouts at 7pm every night and need to manage the lack of electricity. Maybe rolling brownouts is the solution people are proposing?
The other solutions are: figure out storage, or build a gas peaker plant to temporarily provide power in those few hours.
-----------
We focus at the "Duck Curve", because that's clearly where the next brownout will occur without intervention. Secondly: environmentalists are going to block the build of any natural gas plant (even if its necessary), so getting "ahead of the argument" only makes sense.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoYou're committing fallacy number 2 here. Wind power and hydro is a thing. Also, the duck curve problem isn't the need for gas peakers after the sun goes down, it's the speed at which you need to ramp them up from being switched off. If they can't ramp as fast as the solar drops, then you need to start them earlier and end up producing extra electricity (and carbon) that you don't want. The problem you are talking about is called "nightime" and I'll refer you to the footnote in the article that covers this.
- dragontamer 5y ago> You're committing fallacy number 2 here. Wind power and hydro is a thing. Wind is certainly a thing. Its not perfectly reliable, even over large areas (ex: a hurricane on the East Coast would shut down turbines due to too much wind... over a large area). But wind is at least part of the answer to the duck curve. And Hydro is great, but has a peculiar weakness, especially in the context of California's drought conditions. California has the problem of water-shortages as well, which means that hydro-plants are in "water management mode" rather than energy-management. That is to say: Hydro serves two masters: energy management AND water management. If you're using the dam as water-management, you're not necessarily getting the electricity you want at the right times. ---------- I'm not convinced that anything aside from peaker plants really solve the duck curve frankly. Storage will get there eventually. But not today: there needs to be more research and development into storage technologies before we have something large enough. (Either that, or we need to solve the West's water issues, so that hydro plants can be more into energy-management mode rather than the more pressing water-management issues)
- darksaints 5y agoA few hours of storage, every day, at a very predictable time of the day, does not fall into the bucket of "a lot" of storage. That is a very minimal amount of storage. It can barely even be called a buffer. The storage needs that OP mentioned...the kind that gets us from 80% up to 100% renewables is a lot of storage. We're talking multiple days, possibly weeks of storage.
- dragontamer 5y agohttps://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/supply.html https://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/supply.html The supply/demand graphs for the California grid are public for all to discuss. We can look at 9/05/2021, and see that 25GW was demanded at 12-noon, while 36GW was demanded at 7pm at night (hour 19 on the graph). The energy required between 5pm and 10pm on 9/5/2021 (from 17 to 22) is ~37GW per hour. That's 185GW-hrs of energy. Exactly what technology can both store-and-output 185GW-hrs each day, and every day? The "Tesla Megabattery pack" in Australia is 0.3 GW-hrs FYI, to give you what a "very very large" battery can do.
- darksaints 5y agohttps://www.energy.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2019-12/energy_storage_ada.pdf https://www.energy.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2019-12/energy... California already has 4500 GWh of storage. They don't have those peak power levels (currently, 4.5GW) but that's a matter of capital investment into pumps and generators. Not that that is even needed. California has a very large coastline with extremely reliable wind power. For example, there isn't a single spot anywhere along the coast of California that is forecast to have <8kts of wind for more than a day this month. Overprovisioning of wind power is a much bigger part of the solution to the duck curve than storage is.
- aaronblohowiak 5y agoThankfully thermal batteries work just fine. In your example, using a/c before coming home to reduce the usage when sun is setting would be “wasteful”, but if the energy is roughly free it doesn’t matter.
- pfdietz 5y agoThermal storage may also be very useful for intermediate term electric energy storage. https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2020/12/f81/SETO%20PTES%20Workshop%20NREL_Ma.pdf https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2020/12/f81/SETO%20P... This scheme would also allow backstop generation by using a fuel to reheat the storage material, potentially useful for "black swan" prolonged outages. The fluidized bed heat exchangers seem particularly interesting to me, if sufficiently low escape of particulate matter can be achieved.