3 ms·
What difference would it make to you as a user between "this domain doesn't exist" and "this domain doesn't exit, but I refuse to give you valid proof that it d
by detaro 5y ago
What difference would it make to you as a user between "this domain doesn't exist" and "this domain doesn't exit, but I refuse to give you valid proof that it doesn't" (or even no answer at all)?
(NXDOMAIN is also somewhat special in DNSSEC and not signed by default, and requires special mechanisms to handle (NSEC, NSEC3), but IMHO that's not even very relevant to the block scenario)
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> What difference would it make to you as a user between "this domain doesn't exist" and "this domain doesn't exit, but I refuse to give you valid proof that it doesn't" (or even no answer at all)? If you're validating then the second answer should cause you to regard the reply as invalid and retry the request, possibly using a different DNS service.
- detaro 5y agoTrue, a system that is setup with multiple resolvers of which only one censors might actually do get you the page in the end. But from the perspective of the DNS provider, they've done what they "intended"/were forced to do in any case: not give you the correct answer.