5 ms·
> There isn't much storage needed for renewables unless you get to very large numbers. That's categorically false, and the article alludes to this somewhat. Th
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
> There isn't much storage needed for renewables unless you get to very large numbers.
That's categorically false, and the article alludes to this somewhat. The biggest problem with renewables (primarily solar) right now is the "duck curve" [1]. That is, there is plenty of energy available mid-day, but then right when available solar starts to subside is also when you get a sizable demand increase in the early evening (e.g. people getting home from work, cooking, watching TV, doing dishes and laundry, etc.) The slope of that rise means that you not only need as much dispatchable energy sources as before, but you need to ramp them up and down much more frequently, which takes a higher toll on equipment.
Thus, there is a real immediate need for the type of "time shifting" storage the article talks about right now.
1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_curve https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_curve
- pydry 5y agoIt's categorically true. If your energy production is, say, 60% carbon based pretty much every watt generated by wind energy or solar is a watt that doesnt have to be generated by coal or natural gas. "This is the problem with renewables..." - this amusingly sounds a little like an instance of fallacy #1. It becomes "the" problem only when youve got way more renewables capacity than almost everyone has right now.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoPlease take a look at the linked Wikipedia article. The problem with solar is that peak energy demand occurs right when solar output is 0. So it means you still need to have the same power capacity from non-solar sources regardless of whether solar can serve 100% of need at midday (without storage).
- pydry 5y agoThe graph above shows that on non windy days where battery capacity and pumped storage is low you'll have to turn on the gas generators at 5pm. It doesnt exactly render the solar panels pointless.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoPeak energy demand for planning is the yearly peak, not the daily peak. Thats why the duck curve mostly shows up in spring when solar production is high and cooling load is low, and total demand is substantially lower than summer. All grids have a lot of excess production thats only used to meet occaisional peaks. This is not a bad thing in itself and not something new to renewables.
- lukeschlather 5y agoI'm not sure if you're engaging a fallacy, trolling, or you just misread "not much storage needed" as "no need." The argument in the article about storage is literally that there is not much storage needed right now, though that will change in the future that is not a problem to solve right now.
- dragontamer 5y agoCalifornia's grid is already at that point however. Other locations have more flexibility, either due to natural gas peakers or the prevalence of water (pumped hydro is the best battery)
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoIf you read the Wikipedia article I linked, you'll see there is a strong need for storage right now because solar output falls to 0 right as demand peaks. Again, the source article talks about this, but this is also not just a simple problem that can be wished away, and the only "fallacy" is pretending this problem doesn't exist.
- Stupulous 5y agoIf solar is used instead of nonrenewables, regardless of whether load has peaked, you decrease carbon output for each watt generated. In the chart on wikipedia, it looks like you could double California solar output without adding storage. If you want to provide 100% of your energy with solar, you'd need storage. But we're not at that point yet.
- lukeschlather 5y agoAs the article says the need for storage is for storage that can store maybe 1-3 hours worth of grid capacity energy in the afternoon and discharge it late at night. That doesn't seem like a "strong" need for storage. I would say we have a "strong" need for storage if we need the majority of the grid to be operating on storage for at least half the day - "strong need for storage" is not a now problem. If you go out and build that you are likely to lose money. (But if you really think we need that kind of storage, go invest in it and prove me wrong!)
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThere's a non-storage solution to the duck curve "problem" which is just to waste some solar power. As long as you come out ahead overall its still a good idea. It's like saying gas flaring is a problem and we have a desperate need to solve that before getting rid of coal. Well, it would be nice, but overall swapping coal for natural gas is a good thing regardless.
- bryan0 5y ago> There's a non-storage solution to the duck curve "problem" which is just to waste some solar power. Can you explain this? How does “wasting some solar” solve the problem when your max solar output is 0 at peak demand?
- a9h74j 5y agoCan't speak for the poster, but I have seen the argument that if solar and wind can both be over-provisioned by a factor of 3, then storage will not be much of an issue. Fits with a "solar and wind will be too cheap to meter [the amount of cost and materials going into manufacture]" paradigm.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> I have seen the argument that if solar and wind can both be over-provisioned by a factor of 3, then storage will not be much of an issue. That makes 0 sense. If you have 3x needed capacity at midday but 0x capacity at midnight, you could over-provision by 100x - zero times a hundred is still zero.
- lostapathy 5y agoWind capacity at midnight isn't going to be zero over a large enough connected grid.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoSo, the duck curve problem although it caught people's imaginations, no-one really read the original source, so most people dont know what the duck curve problem is. https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2018/3/20/17128478/solar-duck-curve-nrel-researcher https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2018/3/20/1712847... This features some slides from the original use of the term. Note the repeated reference to "Ramp" since that's what the problem was. > We have to be really careful when we talk about something breaking. The only thing that’s going to break is the economics of solar. The lights are gonna stay on. All it comes down to is more curtailment. One of the other solutions was asking the gas plants to ramp faster. The specs said the equipment could do it, it was just institutional inertia as they hadn't needed to do it before and so weren't prepared for it.
- nine_k 5y agoFor countries as large as US, there is another solution: transmission. When evening dusk envelops Boston and New York, there's still plenty of sunlight near Chicago or Saint Louis. Conversely, when it's still morning dusk in Chicago and Saint Louis, sun is already shining over Boston and New York. We of course already have transmission lines all over the country. They can help, given some coordination between energy companies, and maybe upgraded in the east-west direction to help deliver solar energy when its generation increases.