3 ms·
Yes, but more relevant in this case is not carrying around $86,000 in cash. It’s legal but not smart.
by skybrian 5y ago
Yes, but more relevant in this case is not carrying around $86,000 in cash. It’s legal but not smart.
- salawat 5y agoExcuse me, but to hell with this logic. While you agree it is not a crime, the reality of enforcement measures like this means it de facto is considered one in the gestalt of law enforcement. It should not ever be construed as suspicious to carry around large quantities of cash. It is not acceptable to see someone with over 2000 dollars in cash, and assume they are up to something. People are losing sight of the fact that financial privacy was the default for much of history, and the new phenomena of financial surveillance since the 2000's is absolutely a governmental power play, utilizing the financial system as a tool for soft power projection in that the hand that defines the set of transactions that can be conveniently done wields an immense amount of power and influence in people's day to day lives. This is a shining example of how the United States has abandoned any semblance of being a fundamentally high trust society anymore.
- CodesInChaos 5y agoAt least in countries where armed highway robbery is common, which apparently includes the US.
- grayhatter 5y agoYou're right it's stupid this guy clearly deserved to have his money stolen illegally by the government. it's doubly his fault because he allowed the police officer to follow him for long enough that he violated one of the uncountable number of traffic laws. it's Triply his fault because he was trying to be kind and courteous and respectful and cooperative with the officer. what other ways can we blame the guy who had his money stolen for getting his money stolen?
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoAlso, the way he was dressed called for it. Besides, the body has a way to shut down police abuse if you don't want to.
- skybrian 5y agoI didn't say that. What I'm saying is that if "don't tell the police anything" is good advice, "don't carry large amounts of cash" is also good advice. In a just world, neither talking to the police nor carrying cash would result in your money getting stolen.
- grayhatter 5y agoI don't actually agree that carrying a large amount of money is inherently stupid. It's riskier than not carrying cash, but doing something risky is not the same thing as doing something stupid. That said even if it was stupid and it was an obvious mistake. Why mention he made a mistake at all? If not to point out that he shares some of the blame because of that mistake? It might be good advice, but only if it carries an alternative. Pointing out a risk isn't advice, it's a warning. "don't carry large amounts of cash because it might get stolen" vs "electronic transfers between two bank accounts lowers the risk your money will be stolen". But I assume we both agree but that's not really a helpful piece of advice in this case.
- tuukkah 5y agoWe should not blame him as he did nothing wrong and was victimised without reason. On the other hand, it's relevant to remind everyone that replying to questions from the law enforcement can get you in trouble although you did nothing wrong. (I don't think anyone is blaming him for answering as that's the normal thing to do.)