4 ms·
> There are palettes that are designed to be compatible with everyone (except those rare cases with black-and-white vision, and full blindness). Which palettes
by josephcsible 5y ago
> There are palettes that are designed to be compatible with everyone (except those rare cases with black-and-white vision, and full blindness).
Which palettes are these? All of them that I can find still have tradeoffs against different forms of dichromacy.
- acadapter 5y agoThere are always tradeoffs, but most situations don't require more than just a few colors, and it's still a neglected issue even though it can be solved with adhering to some principles. https://davidmathlogic.com/colorblind/ https://davidmathlogic.com/colorblind/ https://www.tableau.com/about/blog/examining-data-viz-rules-dont-use-red-green-together https://www.tableau.com/about/blog/examining-data-viz-rules-...
- josephcsible 5y agoI've seen the Wong palette before, but does it actually solve the problem? In particular, aren't #009E73 and #D55E00 quite difficult to distinguish if you have protanopia or deuteranopia?
- acadapter 5y agoI guess it's not perfect, but the point I'm trying to make is that this is an issue that relates to so many people, that there should be some initiative to create an ISO standard or equivalent.
- jryb 5y agoIt is generally called the Okabe-Ito palette since it was created nine years before the Wong paper. But I digress. Colorblind-friendly color palettes are not sufficient in all cases - even a non-color-deficient person will have trouble distinguishing similar colors when the total area is small (as often occurs in thin lines or dots), or if there are simply too many colors in a plot. A good overview on choosing colors when making figures while keeping color-deficiencies in mind: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7PsbdY3aWdg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7PsbdY3aWdg There really is no perfect solution for all cases, which is why we don't just have a set of hard-and-fast rules for making figures, though there are definitely some choices that are better than others.
- dublin 5y agoMost product designers and developers have NO idea how to handle this properly. I'd done a poor job of it until around 15 years ago, when I was spec'ing out the UI for utility-scale solar monitoring web app. It turns out that in doing that, I discovered my hardware counterpart on the project was colorblind (red/green). We rebuilt the UI using principles from an old Rand Corp study from the 1960s, some of Tufte's work, and the Carolyn Brewer's truly excellent ColorBrewer web app (https://colorbrewer2.org/ https://colorbrewer2.org/), which is the single best tool I know for sorting out how to use color more effectively for info visualization. (Despite what the page says, it's for way more than cartography - I've used ColorBrewer to help refine nearly a dozen IoT data visualization apps over the years. Highly Recommended.