6 ms·
Keep in mind that the devices from manufacturers which people usually "trust" more also have a similar, although less-blatantly-malicious, degree of disobeying
by userbinator 5y ago
Keep in mind that the devices from manufacturers which people usually "trust" more also have a similar, although less-blatantly-malicious, degree of disobeying you by default (silent automatic updates, unremovable system apps, etc.)
You could root it, and that would actually give you full control to delete/install/modify whatever you want.
I think the real lesson here is that if you do not have full control over a device, it is not truly yours and may disobey you.
- throw_nbvc1234 5y agoThey're not the same though; these problems need to be looked at through a combination of ability (to exploit) and motivation. Apple/Google isn't going to try and steal your identity, bank account info, or numerous other "small" things that some unknown and unaccountable company selling malware infected hardware could do. It's like when people state that online voting should be safe because online banking is safe. I'm pretty sure if a nation state really wanted to steal a few grand from your (individual) bank account, they'd be able to do it. But it'd probably cost them more money/power in doing so then it's worth it.
- drran 5y ago> Apple/Google isn't going to try and steal your identity, bank account info, or numerous other "small" things You can believe in that, and trust them, but you cannot prove that, unless you have access to the source of everything installed by Google/Apple, and source of third party apps, favored by Google/Apple. But, even if you're working for a government agency and have access to sources, it's still a monumental task to do, because of the volume of the sources. It's why we, Linux owners, were crying when trivial initd and trivial shell scripts, which are easy to read and understand in about an hour or two, were replaced by Systemd, which may take days just to read source.
- google234123 5y ago> Linux owners, were crying when trivial initd and trivial shell scripts, which are easy to read and understand in about an hour or two, were replaced by Systemd Nah, most Linux owners didn't care and the fact that the most distribution voted with their feet to switch should say enough. Also, full init script were not trivial.
- MereInterest 5y agoMost people don't care about plumbing until it breaks and spews sewage water all across the apartment, after which they'll start having some pretty strong opinions about types of pipes. I didn't care about systemd until its default configuration deliberately broke emacs daemon and tmux, after which I had some pretty strong opinions about systemd. At this point, every distribution disables that setting, but it shows that systemd's developers cannot be trusted to make reasonable defaults, and must be double-checked to avoid blatant foolishness.
- SilverRed 5y agoBeen using systemd for a very long time now and have had no issues. Had a very pleasant time setting up services to start on boot and such. And you can't just pull out "Yeah but it might break sometime in the future" because it never has broken for me, and that same argument can be used against literally every thing in existence. The vast majority of linux users have very positive experiences with systemd and it's cli tools are very good.
- MereInterest 5y agoIn this case, the only reason that it didn't break more widely is because the adults in the room overrode the default KillUserProcesses=yes at the distribution level. This isn't an argument about whether something "might break in the future", as you so kindly put words into my mouth. This is an argument that I do not trust the systemd developers to make reasonable choices, as they have shown a willingness to break long-standing standards for benefits that are marginal at best. Discussion at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11797075 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11797075 Continued defense of the decision as January 2019: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19023232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19023232
- lavabiopsy 5y agoKillUserProcesses=yes is quite a reasonable default for security though, as lingering processes after logout can be an issue on multi-user systems. For example it can be used as protection against fork bombs. I actually have no idea how Linux persisted for so long without something like that, it seems the long-standing standard here was not great. Rememeber that a lot of what a service manager has to do is decide what policies to set based on what security is provided by the kernel, so in some cases all they can do is provide an option and try to set that to the most secure default. I tried to read those threads but I couldn't really gather much information, a lot of the rhetoric is pretty extreme and outrageous. I would suggest to avoid ad hominem comments about "adults in the room" and such, as it distracts from your argument. (more reading on this subject here http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html)
- gnopgnip 5y agoApple, Amazon, Google are not going to steal your credit card, identity, bank account info because you could sue them, and because consumer protections agencies would pursue them. The same is not true if you buy a no name tablet with malware pre loaded
- baybal2 5y ago> Google are not going to steal your credit card ... Last time somebody tried to sue Google for billing them for some random game, it didn't work out that well
- google234123 5y agoNice shifting of the goal posts
- hulitu 5y agoThey will not try to steal it because they have it. Check what analytics has the page where you make payments. Check your browser settings (passwords, credit card data).
- cyanydeez 5y agoif we had to prove technological safety in the modern day world we would all go live in caves. unfortunately, thats a strawman position.
- lavabiopsy 5y ago>Linux owners, were crying when trivial initd and trivial shell scripts, which are easy to read and understand in about an hour or two, were replaced by Systemd, which may take days just to read source. Not sure I understand why you would cry about that, systemd is actually not a very complex project if you're used to low level C daemons. The most complicated part is the d-bus portions, but those are mostly a lot of boilerplate, and you should be understanding it anyway if you use a modern system with d-bus. Trivial initd and trivial shell scripts are also lacking in quite a bit of functionality compared to systemd, at least in my experience those would tend to grow until they became brittle and unmaintanable.
- guerrilla 5y agoYou're moving the goalpost from what Andrew and the person responding said though. The Chinese phone is acting just like a Samsung phone, only a tad bit worse. The Russian phone and the ones you mention are of course another story like you say but that's not what you were responding to, which is a valid point.
- pessimizer 5y ago> Apple/Google isn't going to try and steal your identity, bank account info, or numerous other "small" things that some unknown and unaccountable company selling malware infected hardware could do. They all could do it, but are you aware of any manufacturer-installed malware or rootkits on a device that have? They don't steal your bank account info or impersonate you ever as far as I know, they make money off you in the same way every other company does. If we can't show any instances, then it becomes difficult to find this materially worse than what other tech companies do. It becomes more like embarrassment from being owned by a obscure foreign company rather than a famous American one.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 5y ago> They all could do it That account name is apt. Everybody -could- do it. Even your spouse, your best friend, your parents. They could all steal your shit. But for sanity’s sake a balance has to be struck between trust and paranoia.
- krono 5y agoThe main difference, of course, being that your best friend is someone you could actually make having to face the legal consequences (and/or punch in the face). These oversized American corporations are practically untouchable to the majority of people. They'll pay their laughable fines, pinky promises to better self-regulate for real this time, and move on. Leaving you in the dirt.
- labster 5y agoOnline banking is safe because it is auditable and traceable. Voting has anonymity and chain-of-custody requirements that make doing it online extremely difficult.
- pessimizer 5y agoI agree, this is basically how all tech companies work now. The only thing that holds it back is the outrage cycle, which a) only turns its spotlight on companies above a certain size/visibility, b) can be defeated with a large enough marketing/lobbying spend, and c) can be waited out by companies with other lines of business that bring in profits, and d) can be combated with cycles of withdrawing, quietly reintroducing, then withdrawing again, and reintroducing again until d1.) media outlets get bored with it, or d2.) all other companies in the same line start to do the same thing, a traditional way of price-fixing. Once this happens, the only way you'll be stopped is with legislation, because e.g. every TV has banner ad pop-ups from the manufacturer now.
- jmrm 5y ago> every TV has banner ad pop-ups from the manufacturer now. AFAIK, Samsung and cheap Chinese brands (Vizio, TCL, and similar) do this. Months ago I was between buying a LG or a Sony because they don't have bad reputation around this, and the LG I finally bought haven't any ad. Also, cookies, extra internet stuff, and the Alexa service can be deactivated separately without affecting apps like Netflix
- beebeepka 5y agoVizio, a US company, is the worst offender. These days it's hard to tell what is jingoism, or propaganda, and what is an honest mistake because a product is cheap
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoOf a well-known manufacturers, I noticed Xiaomi to do some real shit: it had an app preinstalled that displayed ads above other apps. But at least when I identified the culprit, it was possible to remove it completely and the problem went away.
- kofejnik 5y agoI had pretty much same experience with my Xiaomi phone (in my case, push ads were coming from a hidden non-removable xiaomi service)
- boondaburrah 5y agoI first ran into Xiaomi when I used a build of their MIUI rom on my Sony Ericsson X10 back in the day. It was amazingly better than default android (2.3/gingerbread era), so I wanted to keep using it. Got a new phone at some point and tried it again, and they were on some real shit by then. All the default built-in programs for like, /music playing/ would force you through a Xiaomi Cloud sign up process just to play music /already on your phone/. Granted, Google is now on the same shit; I found with my latest android they've removed all the basic apps for file browsing, music playing, and the like. Now only "Google Play" versions remain, that of course require a Google account. I feel like the camera and calculator are the only non-play-required default apps left, but I won't be surprised if I find one day that the camera is somehow integrated into Google Photos, which will of course not open until you sign in.
- tsjq 5y agoyes. there are apps in Samsung phones that have disabled buttons to force-quit, disable, & stop notifcations. and these are not even essential apps.