3 ms·
Again this god-of-the-gaps drivel (or dualism-of-the-gaps, since the proponent is atheistic) that claims that since we don't know how a mind arises from the phy
by tsimionescu 5y ago
Again this god-of-the-gaps drivel (or dualism-of-the-gaps, since the proponent is atheistic) that claims that since we don't know how a mind arises from the physical brain it must mean that it doesn't.
The extreme complexity of this theory of the world is of course irrelevant to the kind of people whose end goal is to put art on the same footing as science not only in abstract value (which it surely does) but as an actual method for knowing the world (which is preposterous).
To be clear, if we accept the existence of a non-physical mental realm, we have the monstrous problem of explaining how these two interact, as there are numerous correlations between the two.
- nathias 5y agoGood thing you have solved metaphysics then, care to share your work?
- tsimionescu 5y agoWhile there are massive amounts of work left to actually describe the mechanisms and understand the specifics, I think computation presents an extremely convincing account of how the mind can arise from the body. Metaphysics of course has many other aspects beyond mind/body dualism, and many of those are well outside the realm of what can be scientifically probed. But the origins of the mind in the body and brain are not beyond scientific exploration, and we have been making progress towards them - only baby steps so far, but already too much to keep believing in anything like dualism. In fact, mind/body dualism has not been taken seriously in any scientific circles for at least a hundred years, but it persists in certain philosophical circles, with silly thought experiments such as 'p-zombies'.
- nathias 5y agoYou do understand that the problem isn't in the origin, but type? It doesn't matter if the mind is generated by the body, the issue is if it is reducible to it. This pertains more to ontology as in what is reality and what is is than any particularities of the empirical mechanisms of cognition and neuroscience, substance dualism has nothing to do with science and people who understand the problem know that.
- throwdecro 5y ago> To be clear, if we accept the existence of a non-physical mental realm, we have the monstrous problem of explaining how these two interact, as there are numerous correlations between the two. I suspect a lot of the most interesting investigations of the next few hundred years will be in sorting out whether this is the case, and if so, how it all works.
- tsimionescu 5y agoMapping out the human mind, understanding andaybe even simulating it on a computer will surely be one of the most fascinating directions of study over the next few hundred years, agreed. However, I am not aware of a single argument for dualism beyond 'we don't yet know how it works' or 'I can imagine a p-zombie/qualia therefore it must exist and it disproves that the mind is something like computation'.