4 ms·
The core argument sounds kind of duff >Since neither physics nor Darwinian biology—the concept of evolution—can account for the emergence of a mental world fro
by tim333 5y ago
The core argument sounds kind of duff
>Since neither physics nor Darwinian biology—the concept of evolution—can account for the emergence of a mental world from a physical one, Nagel contends that the mental side of existence must somehow have been present in creation from the very start.
I mean Tesla cars can form a neural network model of the world around them. I don't think you have to go beyond physics to explain this stuff.
- the-dude 5y agoYou assume that our artificial neural networks du jour are enough of a start to get to AGI. I doubt it.
- skohan 5y agoANN's aren't, but the human brain in vivo certainly is
- tim333 5y agoNot really. I'm assuming the artificial neural networks in Teslas have some awareness of their surroundings - where the road goes and so on, and that biological neural networks work in a somewhat similar way but are much more complicated.
- goatlover 5y agoNot for a model, but consciousness is a different 'matter'.
- rixed 5y agoFirst you postulate that it's a different matter, then you wonder where is the science that explains it's existence. Ever considered there might be nothing more to it than what we already know? This is basically the notion of emergence.
- goatlover 5y agoIs the emergence weak or strong? If it's weak, then subjectivity can be reduced to neurons firing or whatever. What does that look like? If it's strong, then you spooky emergence, which means something entirely new — something not entailed by prior physics coming into existence. That would be non-reductive physicalism, but I'm not sure how it's different than property dualism that David Chalmers would endorse.