4 ms·
A few years ago there was some new company (I vaguely recall that it may have been a Kickstarter or similar) touting something like this built into a shell that
by tzs 5y ago
A few years ago there was some new company (I vaguely recall that it may have been a Kickstarter or similar) touting something like this built into a shell that you could put an AA battery in, and the shell would still fit in most AA slots.
They were way overselling its benefits, claiming you would get something like 6 times as much runtime out of your batteries, and it got a lot of negative reviews and debunking at EE tech sites.
I wish someone would make one of these with that sleeve approach, not as some sort of miracle energy extended scam but rather as a voltage curve adjuster.
A common non-rechargeable alkaline battery starts at about 1.5 volts and over its useful life drops fairly steadily to a little over 1 volt, and then rapidly drops to near zero.
A NiMH rechargeable starts at around 1.4, fairly quickly drops to about 1.3, then over most of its life drops fairly smoothly to about 1.2, then starts dropping faster to around 1.1, then rapidly to near zero.
This is why you can use NiMH in devices designed for alkaline batteries even though nominally alkaline batteries are higher voltage. The device has to actually be designed to handle 1 to 1.5 volts, and the NiMH is in that range for nearly all of its discharge curve.
This is also why some devices designed for alkaline report low battery on NiMH long before the batteries actually need changing, and still report low but useful battery level right up until the device stops working. They are estimating battery life by looking at the voltage and fitting that to the alkaline discharge curve to estimate how far the battery has discharged, and it makes the batter level meter on many devices close to useless if you use NiMH.
It would be great if there were a sleeve you could put around your NiMH batteries that would dynamically raise or lower the voltage as the battery discharges to make it match the alkaline curve. Then your battery level indicator on your devices that were designed only for alkaline would work.
- p1mrx 5y agoIf you search for "1.5V rechargeable", there are lots of lithium ion batteries with electronic voltage regulators now. Some designs will step down to ~1V when nearly depleted, so that low battery indicators still work. I'm not sure if an NiMH sleeve was ever practical given the space constraints, but it's kind of moot now that better technology exists.
- Nextgrid 5y agoWhat you're talking about is the Batteriser/Batteroo. It would actually work fine as a voltage stabilizer delivering a constant voltage all the way to the end, but the inefficiencies in power conversion would probably be a major downside (you're losing some energy on the conversion even if the device itself is powered off).
- a1369209993 5y ago> but the inefficiencies in power conversion would probably be a major downside (you're losing some energy on the conversion even if the device itself is powered off). You can get around this[0] by starting the power converter in series with the battery (so the load pulls current through it to start it up) although that's: a: complicated, b: more conversion overhead when it is running, and c: rather difficult when you only have 1.5 volts (or 1 volt) to work with initially, compared to eg a 9-volt or 12-volt battery, which exacerbates problems a and b. /-[starter]-+---\ ˍ˖ | | | | Ξ [regulator] [LOAD] | | | \----+----------/ 0: At least to the standards of the quiescent depletion being a rounding error compared to the battery chemicals breaking down over time.
- squarefoot 5y ago> Batteriser/Batteroo Stay away, they are a well known and debunked scam. https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/batteroo-reboost-make-rechargeables-work-anywhere#/comments https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/batteroo-reboost-make-rec... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batteroo_Boost https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batteroo_Boost https://www.eevblog.com/forum/blog/eevblog-751-how-to-debunk-a-product-(the-batteriser)/ https://www.eevblog.com/forum/blog/eevblog-751-how-to-debunk... Don't miss this one! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OU08zwBH-wo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OU08zwBH-wo
- Nextgrid 5y agoI know they are a scam when it comes to their claims of extended battery life. However, the product itself appears to be legit in terms of being a boost converter if that's actually what you need (in most cases you don't, but I guess running certain devices that need exactly 1.5V and can't take the lower ~1.2V from rechargeable cells would make this a legitimate use-case for it).