2 ms·
We're not morally obligated to accept the status quo just because things always worked this way. Just because some entrenched monopolists that provide negative
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
We're not morally obligated to accept the status quo just because things always worked this way. Just because some entrenched monopolists that provide negative value to society managed to find a comfortable rent seeking position, we're morally obligated to pay tribute? Hell no. It boggles my mind that anyone could look at this and accept it.
> Where else in life is that a valid option? "I'd love to have a snickers bar, but I don't want to pay a dollar for it, so I guess I just take it."
Don't compare physical things to artificially scarce data. They are not the same. Physical things can't be copied infinitely and distributed worldwide at negligible costs.
With data, there is no economy. Economies arise when things are scarce. Data isn't. There is nothing to economize.
> Obviously, there are differences between that example and sci-hub but for the core of the issue, these differences are negligible in my opinion.
These differences are not negligible. Quite the opposite, they are key. The fact is once created data is worth nothing. It's infinitely abundant. Scientists and peer reviewers are the truly scarce resources here and they don't depend on journals to exist.
These monopolists try to make scientific articles artificially scarce but unlike the entertainment industry they don't actually provide any value whatsoever. They're just a brand name.
- kleiba 5y agoYour first paragraph is a nice example for a strawman argument: where have I claimed that we have to "pay tribute" or that I'm in favor of the status quo? About copying vs. physical things - that's one of the aspects I had in mind when I wrote that I'm aware of the differences between that example and the scihub situation, but that I also think that they are not at the heart of the issue. Hence I don't subscribe to your argument against that. Nor do I to your last sentence. Where's the scarcity?
- crazy_horse 5y agoYou are not the only academic that feels this way.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> where have I claimed that we have to "pay tribute" or that I'm in favor of the status quo? You're defending the notion that journals should be able to continue their rent seeking. Did I misunderstand?