8 ms·
Google introduces $50 4G smartphone
- notRobot 5y agoIt'll be really cool if you can flash a custom ROM on this phone. It might soon become the easiest way to get a LineageOS compatible half-decent phone.
- kunagi7 5y agoIt has good enough specs for daily activities like browsing, whatsapp, telegram, signal messaging... Seems like a nice little device. I too hope it gets LineageOS (and if I remember well... The ROM scene is quite active in India. After all, thanks to their scene my old Xiaomi is still alive and running!).
- rex_lupi 5y agoI really don't expect they'll allow the bootloader to be unlocked. but yes, it'd be awesome if they do.
- brian_herman 5y agoAs they said the jurassic park, life finds a way. They will probably reverse engineer it pretty fast.
- unicornporn 5y ago"Google introduces $50 4G smartphone to be able to rob billions of poor people of their personal data". Actually, if you're a surveillance capitalist, it's a very clever move to focus on a markets with users that can't afford to vote with their wallet.
- silverpepsi 5y agoWell that's cynical considering all this surveillance arises out of mere political indifference and/or laziness. Before any falsehoods get mentioned, in the poorest countries you'd better believe there's always a guy ready to make a micro business reflashing things for the technologically unskilled for pennies. If the demand exists. I'd say: less cynically, this whole thing paints a new target for the Chinese to chase with cut throat prices even lower. Meanwhile, as pragmatists, these Chinese manufacturers aren't categorically hesitant to make reflashing hard. Because they're not best friends with US companies to begin with to care.
- shynrou 5y agoYeah it really seems like just undercutting prices, to get their software out there. Similar to Amazons pricing of Echo and Kindle.
- fouc 5y agoFirst thought that occurs to me is that Google is ultimately aiming to benefit from the data. Same reason facebook pays for free mobile data when accessing fb in 3rd world countries.
- andrew_ 5y ago> This also means that companies like Facebook and Google will have greater access to the data of people living in India as more and more become dependent on technology. Therein lies their motivation. Another data grab disguised as good deed. I long for the days when Google was benevolent (or at least the impression they were existed)
- discordance 5y agoIs it possible for a publicly listed company to remain benevolent with the pressure for them to make even more YoY?
- eloff 5y agoIt could, I think many companies do choose the right thing over the profitable thing, at least sometimes. Obviously not all companies, and not everytime. If that caused sufficient lost profits, shareholders might band together to try and change the leadership of the company. I can't cite a specific instance of this happening, I think it's rare. I would be surprised if it hasn't happened though
- scottLobster 5y agoActually in most cases doing the non-profitable thing is literally illegal for executives. At least in the US, CEOs often have a fiduciary obligation to the shareholders baked into their contracts. Granted they can always frame something as a loss leader or public outreach that will indirectly lead to long term profitability for the company, but they can never do charity for charity's sake.
- eloff 5y agoThere is lots of room to frame things though. And companies do charity and political donations and community service all the time. Maybe it's for the tax deduction, but it's also because companies are just people, and those people care about the world they live in.
- 5y ago
- bogwog 5y agoDoesn't Walmart already offer a $20 smartphone (or similarly dirt-cheap)?
- 5e92cb50239222b 5y agoIf only there was a Walmart within 10000 kms around me.
- codeulike 5y agoSeems like it's not much to do with Google other than the fact it runs Android?
- spicybright 5y agoThey definitely do.
- axegon_ 5y agoUnconfirmed specs[1]: * 5.5-inch HD+, 720x1440 * Snapdragon 215 SoC * up to 3GB of RAM * 32GB storage * 2500mAh battery * Android 11 Go Edition If those are indeed the specs, I'd call it a very good option for that price point. [1] https://www.indiatoday.in/technology/features/story/jiophone-next-launch-on-september-10-specs-features-india-price-finance-options-and-all-that-we-know-so-far-1849411-2021-09-05 https://www.indiatoday.in/technology/features/story/jiophone...
- wdb 5y agoSounds like a nice developer phone to build Android apps without high cost. I want to make an Android app and looking for a good dev/test phone
- axegon_ 5y agoMy thoughts exactly to be honest. It's a mid-range phone which, from what I take, won't be crammed up with bloatware. I got a Nokia 5.something(forgot what it was) for my mom some time ago with pretty much identical specs and it was in the $200-ish range. It was like a year ago but I recon it's still in the 130-40$. I was really pleasantly surprised with how well it behaved. The bigger screen aside, in terms of experience it was pretty much identical to my old pixel 2, having used it for ~2 years at the time. It'd be awesome if that phone can deliver something similar for a third of the price.
- mysterydip 5y agoThere's built-in simulators with the android developer tools. Or are you looking to test how it would look/feel on an actual phone (which is a good idea as well)?
- axegon_ 5y agoIn my experience those always behave terrible under Linux, regardless of what hardware I use(including my current dual-xeon with combined 28 cores setup and 64gb of ram). Never tried the emulator under other OS-es, it might be alright there.
- pjmlp 5y agoMeanwhile KaiOS lost access to Google services. https://9to5google.com/2021/08/30/google-assistant-kaios-text/ https://9to5google.com/2021/08/30/google-assistant-kaios-tex...
- thunderbong 5y agoFrom the TFA - > Due to its budget-friendly price, the device will target the lower segment of buyers that cannot afford expensive phones. This means that phone access will be provided to more people as the smartphone connects the users to the rest of the world. > This also means that companies like Facebook and Google will have greater access to the data of people living in India as more and more become dependent on technology. Most of the businesses of the world now operate on the ‘data economy’ where the statistics and data tells them what product the user is more inclined towards. Now the world’s most valuable resource is data, not oil. If this is the official spiel, then I'm aghast!
- beckman466 5y agoGoogle introduces $50 4G smartphone to enable billions of people to get spied on and to use black box Silicon Valley tech that will continue to plunder the commons and continue to commoditize science and technology* There, fixed the title. This has little to nothing to do with helping people in the Global South, it is a calculated investment by Google/Alphabet.
- melomal 5y agoGoogle introduces $50 4G smartphone to enable billions of people to *get more ad revenue.
- beckman466 5y agoYes, yet it doesn't identify the root cause of the rot of this current system though, which is the complete commoditization and monopolization of science and technology. If you are working class and you live in the global south today, your life is often already a living hell because of this [1]. This flavor of hell will slowly 'trickle up' to the north as more and more spaces of the commons are plundered through imperialism, increasing inequality while more and more members of the working class become alienated. [1] https://anthempress.com/kicking-away-the-ladder-pb https://anthempress.com/kicking-away-the-ladder-pb
- EvilEy3 5y agoOh noes! Better to stay without connection then.
- peoplefromibiza 5y agoOr buy Chinese phones, they offer more bang for the buck.
- YLYvYkHeB2NRNT 5y agoCan we agree that MSGOOGLEAPPLE are defacto arms of governments? If the USGOV wasn't getting what they want from them, they would have been broken up a long time ago (antitrust). China would kick manufacturing out.
- glanard_frugner 5y agohow noble of them to enable billions more people to look at ads
- corobo 5y agoNice! This is a great step! I know there's concerns about ads and tracking but honestly getting folks online in an ad supported way from zero is a good start. We can teach everyone how to block ads later if we need to This sort of thing aye, giantg2 (Ref https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25560132 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25560132)
- amadeuspagel 5y agoI can't express my contempt for the people shitting on this. Of course google is a for-profit company, and they do this because it will help them make money. But billions of people will get access to all the worlds information. And yet you see people whining about ads in this thread.
- nerdponx 5y agoMeh. I agree that it's probably doing enough good for the world that Google's ulterior motives are worth ignoring, for the time being. But this level of cynicism and skepticism is absolutely warranted.
- galdosdi 5y agoPerhaps it has to do with the fact that a $50 smartphone introduced in 2021 is in no way anything special or novel. Cheaper usable smartphones have been around for years. The billions are not getting anything they haven't had for years. This is classic PR, inventing a fake reason why a profitmaking move is somehow altruistic. It works on many such as you because many such as you are steeped in the middle class world of $300 flagship phones every couple years and were unaware that decent sub $50 phones have been around for years. Even a pretty nice phone like a Google pixel or Google pixel 2 can be had for about $100 used. They work great still and only have issues because of intentional choices by Google to prevent security updates. It's only a policy thing, no technical cause -- custom ROMs allow latest Android to be used just fine. I can't express my contempt for big companies creating an artificial problem, then trying to get credit for partially fixing it. PS: I relied on the $40 moto G for a few years without issues except "kind of slow". I upgraded to a used Google pixel off eBay for $100 a few years ago. I'm a software engineer and use plenty of popular apps. The forced upgrade treadmill is totally artificial. Just look at the specs on the Google pixel 2 vs pixel 5 sometime. No practical difference, just a bunch of marginal gimmicky stuff like 4 cameras, fingerprint readers that are on the screen instead of the back, etc.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- galdosdi 5y agoThe moto G is or was $40 several years ago. In my cheapskate days I relied on it for a while. Slow but perfectly acceptable. Probably would have performed better if I'd bothered with a custom ROM... I am confused as to what exactly the novelty of a $50 smartphone is at this point. Just another data point I suppose, to support the drumbeat that smartphones are very cheap now, and are the ubiquitous default computing device for most people by now. You can't even keep your kids off smartphones. Their friends will just give them last year's model they were gonna toss in the trash and they'll use it on wifi. Teachers don't even try to keep the kids off the phones in class. When I subbed in a classroom last spring, I once had a kid come up to me to ask me something, and then bury herself in phone distraction before I could even answer, and then act annoyed and surprised that I interrupted her to answer the question she herself had gone out of her way to pose. I was baffled. This was an extreme case but not by that much. The kids are downright addicted, for the benefit of big internet shareholders, as big tobacco once did. When I was that age I was often very bored. This inspired me to find ways to use my brain, to read, write, draw. That we is gone now. Private boredom has been co-opted and is now owned by big internet for their benefit. We had TV to plague us in the same way then of course. But at least TV was less engaging and less omnipresent. As soon as you left the home your mind was free. There are the sidewalk philosophers who say that "things always change, every generation complains of kids these days" but this is a facile and ignorant retort. For 10,000 years technological change has happened yes, but at a much slower rate. What changes today in half a generation, took several generations for most of human history. Parents had a fighting chance to hand down knowledge of how to navigate the world, and to figure out over several generations how best to adapt oneself to new technologies.
- mrpopo 5y ago> Now the world’s most valuable resource is data, not oil. Most valued? Maybe. Most valuable? Definitely not. Energy is largely undervalued today.
- atok1 5y agoIt would 'enable' more people if it ran a free, open source operating system. The only thing it's enabling is another human rights disrespecting corporation.
- cblconfederate 5y agoaren t there other android phones for $50 or less?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Clewza313 5y agoThe key thing here is that it's Reliance Jio rolling this out. Jio is India's largest mobile operator, and in fact the world's biggest operator outside China, with 4x more subscribers than (say) Verizon.
- pkphilip 5y agoThe $50 phone is being brought into India by Reliance Jio. This company abused the law and its political connections to get into a monopoly position. Jio is not known to be a ethical company.
- watchdogtimer 5y agoNot sure what the big deal is about this. I'm posting this on a similar-spec'd Moto E6 I bought new last month for $59 that included enough minutes and data to last me a year (as I mostly use it on wifi). Service is thru Tracfone (a Verizon MVNO). Phone is responsive with no bloatware or forced ads. Phone and plan are available here: https://www.ebay.com/itm/283841361848 https://www.ebay.com/itm/283841361848 .
- lykahb 5y agoRecycling old smartphones solves the problem too. It also creates more local jobs and is better for the environment.
- Alterlife 5y agoLet's rewrite this article in a sentence or two: "Reliance Jio will soon start selling an Android phone which they have called Jiophone next, and it will cost Rs. 3500... probably." This is total spam. The title has nothing to do with the content of the article... The phone isn't introduced by Google, it's introduced by: > Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited, doing business as Jio and guess what, the article is total speculation: > As far as the pricing is concerned, JioPhone could be priced as low as INR 3499. Emphasis on 'could be' added by me. It isn't released yet and apparently the author is just guessing what it could cost... based on what? Besides, how is it surprising that this is subsidized? This device is network locked and handicapped. Jio phones are totally handicapped. They don't even allow users to open a wifi hotspot because that would compete with their wireless routers. Maybe that's what they are 'collaborating with google' on. This isn't news it's an advertisement.
- Abishek_Muthian 5y agoThe main takeaway for me is RIP kaiOS i.e. Proprietary successor of Firefox OS because earlier JioPhones ran them which surprisingly led KaiOS to get the 3rd largest market share in mobile OS. What ever reasons(App ecosystem majorly) led Jio (An investor in KaiOS) to ditch KaiOS is applicable to all other manufacturers too, Especially if Google(another investor) partnering with them(Android Go? Subsidizing HW?).
- Markoff 5y agonothing to do with Google, this is phone from Indian carrier Jio also the price doesn't seem particularly cheap, I can buy Cubot Note 7 here in Czechia with 2y EU warranty for 70$ incl. all fees without any subsidies from any carrier like Jio, also 5.5" display, also 2/16, also 4G, Android 10 I'm sure I could buy better configuration for less than 50$
- Shadonototro 5y ago> The most affordable 4G smartphone of India, JioPhone Next will began pre-booking from next week. The phone has been created in collaboration with Google. Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited, doing business as Jio, is an Indian telecommunications company and a subsidiary of Jio Platforms, headquartered in Mumbai, under the chairmanship of Mukesh Ambani. It's not google, it is Jio