5 ms·
Why would anyone not do this? Do people enjoy enriching copyright monopolists by paying hundreds of dollars for 24h access to one paper that may or may not have
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
Why would anyone not do this? Do people enjoy enriching copyright monopolists by paying hundreds of dollars for 24h access to one paper that may or may not have dubious methodology? That's fucking stupid and these paid journals can't go bankrupt soon enough.
- capableweb 5y agoIf you talk with non-scientists, you'll realize that most people are happy to pay the fees as they don't really understand how things work in the background. While they think they are supporting science by paying the fees, the reality is that everyone is paying the publisher and the publisher takes all the fees to themselves. But when you mention this to non-scientists, they'll gasp in non-belief.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> But when you mention this to non-scientists, they'll gasp in non-belief. They gasp in pure joy. Back in school I had a professor who paid out of his own pocket for access to one particular journal in order to bring scientific articles to class. Our library didn't have access to this journal. I was disgusted by how these journals were exploiting him. I looked for a way to fix that and discovered Sci-Hub for the first time. He was overjoyed when I showed him that. Our classes became better, richer. He could finally bring whatever material he felt was important. The damage these copyright monopolists cause cannot be quantified. There's also the usability. When I told my classmates about Sci-Hub, they were also very happy because they no longer had to go through our library in order to access scientific articles. They can just download whatever they want. This is how things should be.
- bo1024 5y agoThe top comment on this HN submission at the moment has this misunderstanding.
- GuB-42 5y agoJust curious, who are these non-scientists who will pay for scientific papers? Journalists? I can't imagine people whose work do not depend on these papers pay the exorbitant fees. And those who need scientific papers for work are generally the ones we call scientists.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoDoctors came to mind. They depend on scientific evidence for their practice but most do not publish scientific articles.
- ta988 5y agoPeople with a disease and searching for informations about it. You can't imagine how many patients I've heard payed for those articles. And $30-$60 is a lot for just ten pages...
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI never considered that. These monopolists will exploit even sick people. It's disgusting.
- sircastor 5y agoI agree with you. I think the monopolists would respond that this is research that should be done by the doctor, not the patient. Patients doing their own research can be dangerous.
- ta988 5y agoYes and if my wife didn't bring articles and did her own research to her doctors she would likely be dead by now... Patients bringing info to doctors is extremely common. It also mean that doctors have to deal with a lot of BS unfortunately.
- AlbertCory 5y ago> "who are these non-scientists who will pay for scientific papers? Journalists?" Patent researchers. I was one. Except I never paid a fee just to look at a paper, purely because I don't know if it's any good until I read it, and there are HUNDREDS of papers I have to skim. You can always find it or something very similar for free. Once we know it's an important paper, then our outside law firm would pay the fee, and it would disappear in their monthly bill.
- cmg111 5y agoI'd still be afraid of PDF exploits when downloading papers from Belarus, where the government apparently tolerates the operation. Many scientists are juicy targets.
- White_Wolf 5y agoThe same would apply to any country with a surveilance program.
- NavinF 5y agoPDF parsing and rendering has been sandboxed for over a decade: https://chrome.googleblog.com/2010/11/pdf-goodness-in-chrome.html https://chrome.googleblog.com/2010/11/pdf-goodness-in-chrome... The idea of depending on your government to protect you from exploits is insane. Anyone in the world can upload a shady PDF to a website hosted in any country and suffer zero consequences.
- flayy 5y agoUsing Chrome in the pursuit of privacy is a joke, right? Regarding PDF specifically: https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-chrome-zero-day-used-in-the-wild-to-collect-user-data-via-pdf-files/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-chrome-zero-day-used-in... https://windowsreport.com/google-chrome-pdf-security-bug/ https://windowsreport.com/google-chrome-pdf-security-bug/ Who said anything about "depending on the government" or uploading PDFs? This subthread is about downloading from Elsevier directly vs. downloading from SciHub.
- joshuaissac 5y ago> This subthread is about downloading from Elsevier directly vs. downloading from SciHub. The reply was to a comment about downloading from Belarus "where the government apparently tolerates the operation" "of PDF exploits" according to the commenter.
- Saris 5y agoTo be fair security and privacy can be different things.
- kleiba 5y agoI work as a scientist, and I never download pirated papers. Why? Mostly because I don't have to - almost all relevant papers are accessible to me straight up, either because the authors / publishers have made the paper available for free themselves or because I have access to the publication through my university's library. But I am in Computer Science - I know that the situation is not at all the same in other disciplines. I think if you want to be cited, it is kind of silly to publish at a venue where your paper is not immediately accessible - there's usually enough other papers to cite, so it's in your own interest to be available. That said, regarding the original question ("why would anyone not do this"), I know from previous discussions here on HN that I'm part of a small minority, but I wouldn't do it because I find it unethical. There's lots of things that I wouldn't mind having / owning but I cannot afford them. Just because they might be available through non-official channels for free does not mean that using that option is the right thing to do. In this line of thought, I also think it is irrelevant whether putting publicly funded research results behind a paywall is ethical on the publisher's side: two unethical acts don't make an ethical one.
- Retr0spectrum 5y agoI used to have access to papers via my university, but I never used that access. The UX of scihub is infinitely better. Anything else just added unnecessary friction to my research process.
- kleiba 5y agoThat must be quite the convoluted interface at your university then - at my university, access is given automatically based on my being part of the university network. It is absolutely transparent, I only notice when I'm at home and forgot the turn on the VPN to be part of the university network.
- matthewdgreen 5y agoMany of us spent a good chunk of the past 18 months outside of our University network. Sci-Hub turns out to be faster than the University VPN.
- AmIDev 5y agoMy employer pays for papers we need on a per-paper basis, and recently got subscription for one of the publishers as that was cheaper. They simply want to avoid lawsuits. I'm sure that outside of workplace, every employee uses sci-hub.