4 ms·
It is clear that nobody buys in to the premise of the War on X because usually the premise is senseless. There is no connection at all between 9/11 and the nece
by roenxi 5y ago
It is clear that nobody buys in to the premise of the War on X because usually the premise is senseless. There is no connection at all between 9/11 and the necessity for the US to have launched what turned out to be a 20 year occupation of Afghanistan. None. The punishment and crime are not just disconnected but absurdly independent of each other. And the response did far more damage than anything else to American freedoms.
There is a probably a nice write-up somewhere of how that is the point; some sort of tribe bonding exercise or something. Showing that people pull together as a community because they are a community rather than because of a rational reason. The fact that the premise is farcical isn't a factor. Don't expect logical consistency.
- zepto 5y agoI actually agree with you that the war in Afghanistan was an absurdly wrong move, and have thought this since it started. However this statement: > There is no connection at all between 9/11 and the necessity for the US to have launched what turned out to be a 20 year occupation of Afghanistan. None. Is simply not true.
- atoav 5y ago> There is no connection at all between 9/11 and the necessity for the US to have launched what turned out to be a 20 year occupation of Afghanistan. None. Of course there is a connection. Poltics felt obligated to do something. In purely practical terms the US (and the world) might have been better off if instead of going for a war in Afghanistan, the US did nothing instead (except for a proper investigation of course). But wars are not often about purely practical matters anyways. Sometimes they are more domestic politics than foreign, sometimes they are more about telling and selling stories than about survival.