3 ms·
> premodern China never really had decentralized steelworking There was formally a state monopoly on iron that would have made local smithing illegal, but ther
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> premodern China never really had decentralized steelworking
There was formally a state monopoly on iron that would have made local smithing illegal, but there were not enough state smithies to serve that purpose, so the general assumption is that illegal smithies were common.
> genghis khan probably came from a smithy family btw
I have not heard of this and it is facially implausible; the Mongols were not a metalworking people.
- gradschoolfail 5y agoFrom wikipedia: “ Paul Pelliot saw that the tradition according to which Genghis was a blacksmith was unfounded though well established by the middle of the 13th century.[27]” It seems at least the concept of blacksmiths was familiar to the Mongols before or around the time they went into china. Thats why I explicitly stated “steelworking” instead of “ironworking”. Although they couldnt do it in large quantities the common European smith could use it to enhance his iron products[1] Whereas even the quality of the steel used by the experts in China (even by the 1600s) is questionable. [2] [1] https://the-orb.arlima.net/encyclop/culture/scitech/iron_steel.html https://the-orb.arlima.net/encyclop/culture/scitech/iron_ste... [2] https://www.tf.uni-kiel.de/matwis/amat/iss/kap_a/advanced/aa_2_2.html https://www.tf.uni-kiel.de/matwis/amat/iss/kap_a/advanced/aa...
- BadInformatics 5y agoBronson and Pigott were a nice read, but it's unclear where Föll is getting most of his conjecture from because they certainly don't talk about it. Frankly, the whole piece smacks of the same Diamond-esque "they made fireworks, we made guns" trope that has been thoroughly torn apart since. Now to his credit, he does claim ignorance at the top of the page, but that seems to be quickly forgotten given how much hyperbole is spewed later on. [1] is a better lay overview of medieval-era steel-making. And for a great breakdown of forces behind European success in the modern era, see Brett Devereaux's series on EU4 [2] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5djVkOgu8vs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5djVkOgu8vs [2] https://acoup.blog/2021/05/28/collections-teaching-paradox-europa-universalis-iv-part-iv-why-europe/ https://acoup.blog/2021/05/28/collections-teaching-paradox-e...
- gradschoolfail 5y agoIt reads like Foell was mostly citing Wagner, not B or P. Did you read those?