4 ms·
I don't see how the Cobra Effect is even theoretically possible here. To have a possible Cobra Effect you have to be (1) paying to try to achieve a desired outc
by tzs 5y ago
I don't see how the Cobra Effect is even theoretically possible here. To have a possible Cobra Effect you have to be (1) paying to try to achieve a desired outcome, and (2) what you actually payout for is when people do something that correlates with leading to the desired outcome put does not correlate perfectly. People may then find that some of those things that achieve the payout but do not correlate with the desired outcome are easier to do then the things that do correlate with it.
In the original Cobra Effect example the desired outcome was a reduction in the number of wild cobras. The thing that earned the payout was turning in a dead cobra. The way to turn in dead cobras that was easier and did not correlate with a reduction in wild cobras was breeding cobras to kill and turn in.
In the San Fransisco case the desired outcome is that a group of people don't shoot anyone for a month. The payout is earned by not shooting anyone for a month. As far as I can tell not shooting anyone for a month perfectly correlates with not shooting anyone for a month, and hence no Cobra Effect is possible.
- waterhouse 5y agoSo they're paying a specific group of 10 people $300 per month. Suppose someone says, "I'm not in that group, but I'd like to be in it. How do I get into it?" Well... the article specifies "people at high risk of shooting someone", and implicitly it would be "people that those administering this program are aware are at high risk of shooting someone". So, I guess, if you didn't already have a gun, you could get one, and start waving it around; or get into public arguments in bars and do low-level violent crime or theft; or find out whatever risk factors the administrators are specifically looking for, and start exhibiting them. Probably you wouldn't just deliberately go shoot someone, because you might end up in jail; but you might start putting yourself in situations where shooting started looking like your best option.