4 ms·
[edit:] The depiction was never discussed, it was about the wedding not the cake. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masterpiece_Cakeshop_v._Colorado_Civil_Rights_C
by Retric 5y ago
[edit:] The depiction was never discussed, it was about the wedding not the cake.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masterpiece_Cakeshop_v._Colorado_Civil_Rights_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masterpiece_Cakeshop_v._Colora... informing the couple that he did not create wedding cakes for marriages of gay couples owing to his Christian religious beliefs, although the couple could purchase other baked goods in the store. Craig and Mullins promptly left Masterpiece without discussing with Phillips any of the details of their wedding cake. In other words he was unwilling to provide any cake for this purpose regardless of what was shown on it.
The law isn’t that literal for good reason. Put another way saying it’s ok to reject a mortgage because it’s a black mortgage rather than a black applicant is silly. It’s clear in the case the rejection was based on sexual orientation.
A bakery can’t reject an order because it’s for a religious ceremony due to the religion associated with that ceremony. However, it’s likely a bakery could reject being part of any wedding independent of religion or sexual orientation.
Anyway, the same baker is in court over refusing to make birthday cake for transgender woman.
- gmadsen 5y agoim not following the analogy. What is a black mortgage?
- Retric 5y agoA mortgage to a black person. The point is you can’t reject something that’s a proxy for a protected class. For example only staffing your call center with blonds.
- nonameiguess 5y agoIt's probably obvious, but you can do this when you have a legitimate business reason for it. Hooter's is within its rights to hire only women with a DD+. More germanely, a casting director can put out a call for actors only of a specific race.
- Retric 5y agoYep, which is why I said call center. If the customers can’t see the staff then it’s hard to argue blond hair is anything but a proxy.
- gmadsen 5y agothats different than the cake though. If the bakery would sell a non designed cake to a gay couple, or if they refused a straight couple to make a gay cake, that is different than your example. To be clear, I'm not sticking up for the bakery, it just doesn't seem like a clear proxy like you are saying
- Retric 5y agoOnly the context was discussed not the details. In other words they could have been trying to order a cake saying “Happy Birthday“ to be used in a wedding for some in joke and the baker wouldn’t have known. And in context a strait couple can’t have a gay wedding, the difference is inherently gender dependent thus making it a proxy. [edited for clarity]
- whiddershins 5y agoA straight couple could purchase a cake for a gay wedding. And the baker wouldn’t have sold it to them. Therefore the baker is not discriminating against gay people. The baker won’t sell cakes for gay weddings to anyone, regardless of race, religion, or sexual orientation.
- cpartq 5y agoHe made quite beautiful artistic cakes. He offered any other cake than a wedding cake, because other cakes aren't personal. A mortgage is impersonal, this is more like requiring an LGBTQIA+ artist to paint a picture of Trump against their will.
- Retric 5y agoNo it was the wedding cake specifically that was rejected without discussing details, they could order other baked goods as long as they where not used as a wedding cake. “Masterpiece's owner Jack Phillips, who is a Christian, declined their cake request, informing the couple that he did not create wedding cakes for marriages of gay couples owing to his Christian religious beliefs, although the couple could purchase other baked goods in the store. Craig and Mullins promptly left Masterpiece without discussing with Phillips any of the details of their wedding cake.“ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masterpiece_Cakeshop_v._Colorado_Civil_Rights_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masterpiece_Cakeshop_v._Colora...
- alfredochips 5y agoRight. They might have wanted a cake with gay symbols on it. But Phillips made his mind when the couple said they wanted a wedding cake for their wedding. It wouldn’t have mattered if it’s a pride flag or an asteroid on the wedding cake.
- luckylion 5y ago> A bakery can’t reject an order because it’s for a religious ceremony due to the religion associated with that ceremony. Are you sure about that? Like, a cake depicting human sacrifice to Satan, and your random baker couldn't say "uhm, no, I don't do those"?
- Retric 5y agoRejection was based on context not content. “Masterpiece's owner Jack Phillips, who is a Christian, declined their cake request, informing the couple that he did not create wedding cakes for marriages of gay couples owing to his Christian religious beliefs, although the couple could purchase other baked goods in the store. Craig and Mullins promptly left Masterpiece without discussing with Phillips any of the details of their wedding cake.”
- xcdfgvd 5y agoSo if the cake is going to be used during a Satanic human sacrifice ritual, they need to make it?
- heavyset_go 5y agoThat might make them accomplices/accessories in a crime if they knew about the human sacrifice, so I'd hope not.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Retric 5y agoClearly religion isn’t a blanket free pass to do anything, otherwise the baker would have won the case. This is needed as religions do actually prescribe stoning people to death for example. So a symbolic ritual sacrifice is protected, but an actual human sacrifice isn’t.