3 ms·
Self-reply answering a number of points: - I'm familiar with Eddington's "arrow of time" and the concept's fascinated me since I first encountered it listening
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Self-reply answering a number of points:
- I'm familiar with Eddington's "arrow of time" and the concept's fascinated me since I first encountered it listening to a lecture by Stephen Hawking, and reading his own A Brief History of Time. (The lecture was effectively a chapter from the book.)
- The question of whether or not all clocks are entropic has bothered me ever since.
- It's relatively recent delvings into origins of technology, and recognising that astronomy was in large part the science of time, as well as the fact that most of our historical measures of time were based on astronomical phenomena (the day, month, and year, as well as multiples and subdivisions --- reliance on nonastronomical standards is a modern departure largely undertaken for accuracy but not basis).
- In the Seven Liberal Arts, the trivium concerns data input/output and processing (grammer: parsing input, logic: processing, rhetoric: output), whilst the quadrivum is quantitative: arithmatic is quantity, geometry is quantity in space, music is quantity in time, and astronomy is quantity in space and time. That adds an additional dimension to astronomy, but again, the role of ancient astronomers in timekeeping, prophecy, and navigation remains significant.
Reducing my argument above to its essence, I like the formulation I arrived at in one subthread here, a variant on the "if a tree falls in a forest" conundrum:
If a dead planet orbits a black dwarf whilst tidally locked in an utterly dark Universe, does time exist?
Is the observer necessary?
- nextaccountic 5y agoIf the system returns back to the exact same configuration (highly improbable because there are other forces besides gravity), I think we could say that time makes a loop, because any observer can't distinguish whether it's currently in time t or time t+P where P is the period. Incidentally, I've been thinking about a time travel game along those lines: if you ever return to a save point but the game is at a previous configuration, this counts as a time travel (which can be, like.. a multiverse travel if time branched out.. which amounts to the same thing), just like if you selected a time travel in the UI.. two game states can't be in a different time if they are identical. Of course if the mechanic is just this, then this is just a regular save/load state with infinite save lots. Which is a funny observation. Then I need to add other mechanics on top, like carrying things from a timeline to another, which is where the physical analogy would break up.
- nextaccountic 5y agoAnother observation, if we had two different timelines that end up in the same exact state, then this could be an explanation on why time isn't reversible: when we go back in time there's multiple possible pasts, and by looking at the present state of the world we don't know which timeline is the real past (if there's ever such a thing). The many-worlds quantum interpretation says that, likewise, when we go to the _future_ we also have multiple timelines, and nature somehow just pick one arbitrarily, and this becomes "our" timeline. Then to reverse time, perhaps it's sufficient to employ the same mechanism, but in reverse. (Perhaps there's already beings that live backwards in time, it's just that "their" timeline works that way. Like the movie Tenet). Or even, perhaps each time the timeline splits in the future direction due to quantum phenomena, it also equally splits when going in the past, in the exact same way. (Well I'm trying to recover some symmetry here, but not sure if it works)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]