4 ms·
I'm not saying the experiments aren't interesting oh, they are. The fungi shows an amazing amount of sophistication and conditional response. I do however think
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
I'm not saying the experiments aren't interesting oh, they are. The fungi shows an amazing amount of sophistication and conditional response. I do however think that anthropomorphizing it actually detracts from the exciting response observed. Framing it as being mindful intelligent and having memory implies some concept of mind which clearly isn't there and isn't an is misleading. This distracts from the interesting chemistry and physics problems of how conditional responses are formed and information is stored. If one were to push back on a physics explanation, what would the alternative be: Magic? A soul? Some sort of new decentralized cognitive process never seen elsewhere in nature capable of awareness and decision making?
- jancsika 5y ago> I do however think that anthropomorphizing it actually detracts from the exciting response observed. Sure, we don't want scientists to overestimate the impact of new findings. And perhaps that's what is going on here. But it's daft to try to convince others to be more sensible about new findings by offering up an unscientific musing about an alternative to an existing field. Especially when that musing includes no experimentation, no predictions, and no citations. As unfortunate as it is, sometimes there is just no way around reading an article and replying based on the actual content of it.