3 ms·
We would have a system which would go back to its original state every day, each rotation. This means there would be no way to discern how many days have passed
by dredmorbius 5y ago
We would have a system which would go back to its original state every day, each rotation. This means there would be no way to discern how many days have passed, as the system would be in the same configuration as it was at the beginning of the rotation.
That's precisely what bodies in angular rotation or orbits do.
"One day looks pretty much like another."
For a sundial, the (apparent) movement of the shadow provides the marker of time throughout the day. It (mostly) doesn't indicate the passage of time greater than a day (not strictly true: see the annalema). But within any 24 hour period, you've got a timekeeping piece in which entropy plays no role in the measurement of the passage of time itself, but only as a signalling mechanism (casting a shadow).
In order to complete the clocked-ness, you either need a second repeating phenomenon (e.g., Earth's rotation vs. Moon's orbit, Earth's rotation vs. Earth's orbit). In which case with an external recording mechanisms the passage of time can be noted.
But the fundamental timekeeping mechaism, the phenomenon which is regularly occurring with time occurs without discernable entropic decay, once set in motion.
The rotation or orbit is the escapement here. It's functioning without an entropic drive.
Pointing out that an entropic flow might be used independently of a sundial does not explain how it relates to the sundial.
- Hayarotle 5y agoA sundial uses more than just angular rotation and orbits, though. You can't measure time with angular rotation alone. Using a sundial as a clock (by registering its cycles or by looking at it and remembering how many cycles it went through) inevitably increases the system's entropy. You don't need a second repeating phenomenon, just as you don't need a second pendulum in the pendulum clock. The pendulum might repeat its motion at a short interval, but is able to measure intervals longer than its period. If you have a sundial that works without increasing entropy, it doesn't work as a clock. Just as a perpetual motion pendulum alone wouldn't work as a clock. Using other orbits doesn't change that. You need the entropic flow to register the passage of time. In the case of the sundial, it can be done by recording its cycles. A sundial on a rotating planet isn't able to measure time within its cycle without increasing entropy any more than a pendulum is able to measure time within its period without increasing entropy. They're not able to do that. A Sundial without light and a recording device isn't a clock, just as a lone pendulum with no energy losses and no recording device isn't a clock.
- dredmorbius 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28417247 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28417247
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]