3 ms·
One difference between HPV vaccination in boys and COVID vaccination in kids is that if the unvaccinated boy eventually does give HPV directly to a girl she pro
by tzs 5y ago
One difference between HPV vaccination in boys and COVID vaccination in kids is that if the unvaccinated boy eventually does give HPV directly to a girl she probably will not be his mother or sister. A kid spreading COVID on the other hand does have a good chance of giving it to siblings and parents.
Does that make any difference ethically?
In the HPV case you are weighing risk to the boy against potential harm to a vague ill-defined community. He's only endangering his sister or mother by perhaps slightly raising the level in the general population and so slight increasing the chances someone unrelated to him they have sex with will give it to them.
In the COVID case you are weighing risk to the child against risk of harm to the rest of the child's immediate family. Losing immediate family can be pretty harmful to a child, perhaps enough to ethically justify taking some risk to the child to avoid it.
- asdfologist 5y ago-
- michaelmrose 5y agoVaccination decreases likelihood of transmitting Delta but doesn't absolutely prevent it. Vaccination prevents downstream spread and thus deaths and given the amplification of increasingly larger downstream generations this effect could still be very large when considering the entire population.
- mythrwy 5y agoHow much does vaccination decrease the likelihood of transmission of Delta? Does anyone know this?
- simonh 5y ago> Does that make any difference ethically? No, ethically your only concern is the patient.
- robocat 5y agoAnd the patient is affected if his parents or grand-parents are hospitalised or die. Not so much if a sexual partner dies of cervical cancer decades later.
- simonh 5y agoYes of course, but they are not affected medically. I’m not saying it’s right or wrong, but that’s the standard.
- zarzavat 5y agoThat's not the case. Otherwise living organ donation would be unethical. Clearly it is ethical even though it contains much more risk to the donor than a COVID vaccination.
- tialaramex 5y agoDonation by competent adults comes down to a similar rationale to cosmetic surgery. The donor says this is specifically what they want to happen, the medic is confident that the donor understands the risk and consents to this procedure despite it, the benefit is to their well being. The extent to which humans are usually capable of meaningful consent is dubious, which is also a problem in other aspects of life, but that's the best option we have available. Donation in children or the mentally disabled is a big problem because now we're dealing with trying to guess whether a person has the capacity to understand and then consent to the risk. On the one hand it might seem safer to always say "No" but this denies their autonomy.