3 ms·
When 70% of people weren't affected by the experiment (13% were wearing masks before the experiment started. 60% of people didn't wear a mask after the experime
by dragontamer 5y ago
When 70% of people weren't affected by the experiment (13% were wearing masks before the experiment started. 60% of people didn't wear a mask after the experiment), then of course the numbers are going to be small.
Seeing a measurable difference when the population only changed from 13% mask to 40%ish mask usage is pretty outstanding IMO.
- kragen 5y agoI don't think that's correct; see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28407881 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28407881 for the argument in more detail.
- dragontamer 5y agoMy argument and your argument are seemingly unrelated. That means that the full matrix of situations are available: I'm correct and you're correct. I'm correct and you're wrong. I'm wrong and you're correct, and finally I'm wrong and you're wrong. ---------- So lets just try again from the top. The study shows that an 8-week mask-awareness campaign in Bangladesh across 300 villages (+300 "control" villages 2+km away where mask-awareness did NOT happen) leads to a 29% increase in mask usage and an 11% decrease in COVID19 cases. Is there anything wrong with this new, revised statement I made? It seems to be the big "A / B" test that everyone's wanted for mask studies.
- kragen 5y agoOh, I think we totally agree on the facts of what happened! Except that I don't think it was an 11% decrease in covid cases, but a slower increase that ended up 11% lower. But you said it was "pretty outstanding IMO" and I think the opposite: I think it shows that an increase of 29 percentage points in mask usage had so little effect on covid risk that it could only be reliably detected with sophisticated statistics and experimental design, and even then only at a group level, not an individual level.