3 ms·
There is a long standing debate on the ethics. High seas piracy is bad because when the pirate steals, they deprive someone else of their property. But in the
by jedberg 5y ago
There is a long standing debate on the ethics. High seas piracy is bad because when the pirate steals, they deprive someone else of their property. But in the digital realm, no one is deprived of anything when someone else steals it, because in almost every case, the person was not willing to pay for it anyway, so there is no loss of revenue.
Honestly, there isn't a whole lot of difference between something like open core software or open source with commercial support and commercial software that is easy to pirate. In both cases, the people who are willing to pay will pay and the rest don't.
- oauea 5y agoIn some cases it may even increase revenue. There's been multiple times I've pirated a game, only to buy it later to get easy access to updates. Of course a good demo system would help with this, and Steam's refund policy is somewhat a step in the right direction.
- Dumblydorr 5y agoIs it true that no one is deprived of anything in digital piracy? There is surely a group who would not pay anyway, but isn't there another group who would begrudgingly pay but pirates if possible? Does this not deprive the software makers of a bit of sales? Is this a marginal bit or a huge amount of the sales? And does the piracy potentially lead to popularization and more sales? It sounds very tricky to measure these phenomena in software. In music, I think the majority of musicians themselves live off of their fans coming to shows or a small percentage buying the albums, and side-gigs haha. There are probably only dozens lucky enough to get huge payoffs from digital sales.
- foxfluff 5y ago> Does this not deprive the software makers of a bit of sales? I'd welcome a more neutral phrasing for this though. Yes, it may change people's behavior. But depriving someone of something sounds like something they had is taken away from them; but these are not sales or property they had, rather it's something they perhaps would have had if the world were different. Now, a lot of things can "deprive" me of things that I'd like to have but never did.. As you say, it's very difficult to measure. Actually, it's not something that can be measured, because it's a world of hypotheticals. It's like measuring how tall you would be if you had lived in the 1500s. You don't measure that. If piracy isn't a choice, then I might look for an alternative.. and if I find an alternative that pleases me, then I'm less likely to deal with the author of the original un-pirateable software, thus "depriving" them of something they perhaps could have had if they had first gained me as a user somehow.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]