3 ms·
> The entire concept of a backdoor that only the good guys have the keys too is so moroinic as to make my blood boil. Uhm...isn't the whole basis of modern cry
by tzs 5y ago
> The entire concept of a backdoor that only the good guys have the keys too is so moroinic as to make my blood boil.
Uhm...isn't the whole basis of modern cryptography the idea that you can have keys that only the good guys know? Every time you use an HTTPS site for example you are relying on the existence of keys that only the good guys know. Every time you use an end to end encrypted messaging system you are relying on the existence of keys that only the good guys know.
The issue with backdoors is not keeping keys secret. It is keeping others from also installing backdoors.
- dylan604 5y agoI'm thinking you're not understanding the problem correctly. Backdoors mean that people with that access can read things without having the shared keys. You and I exchange keys so we can communicate privately. Because only you and I have those keys, nobody else can read those messages. However, because the TLAs have backdoor access, you and I and the TLAs can read the messages. However, you and I don't know that or at least we're unaware when it is occurring (because we read things like HN and are at least aware of backdoors). Now, bad actor #1 discovers the backdoor and jimmies the lock, and now they can read our "private" messages. Then bad actor #2 comes along and releases to the public how to use the backdoor on anyone's private messages, and now nothing is private and the crypto is a waste of energy. Then the TLAs come along and make it illegal to distrubte code that allows access to the backdoors and someone releases a new t-shirt. The rest of the world sits back and says "I told you so".
- asimpletune 5y ago> Uhm...isn't the whole basis of modern cryptography the idea that you can have keys that only the good guys know? No it in any way, but based on your other examples, maybe you're thinking about certificate authorities?