5 ms·
When the Caldor fire (now 210 thousand acres, 328 mi^2!) was smoking up Placerville, the downtown Home Depot had, at the main entrance, a big stack of 20x24x1-
by ncmncm 5y ago
When the Caldor fire (now 210 thousand acres, 328 mi^2!) was smoking up Placerville, the downtown Home Depot had, at the main entrance, a big stack of 20x24x1-inch #9 furnace filters, box fans, and rolls of tape, with one all constructed sitting on top, running, black with trapped smoke.
Kudos to HD for not jacking up prices.
It is best to make them with a four inch thick filter, which HD does not stock, and higher than a #9, likewise, bought online. You can stack a #8 in front of a #17, to make the ~$100 #17 last longer, and stack two box fans (one intake, one exhaust) to get more suction. Maybe stack #8/fan/#17/fan, to keep the fans clean.
But the single one-inch #9 filter cleared the smoke from my whole house in no time flat! Don't let "best" stop you from doing "good".
An advantage you have from high airflow is that particles that make it through the filter once are likely to get trapped the next time around, or the 20th. Atomizing some water ought to make filters momentarily stickier, until it dries.
Fan blades getting dusty can cut airflow in half! (Same on laptop cooling fans; use a vacuum cleaner on your laptop air path.)
- Johnny555 5y agoKudos to HD for not jacking up prices. Not sure all the credit goes to them since if they jacked up the price during the fire, they'd be violating price gouging laws. But it is nice that they put the components for a DIY filter all in once place https://www.oag.ca.gov/consumers/pricegougingduringdisasters https://www.oag.ca.gov/consumers/pricegougingduringdisasters
- ncmncm 5y agoThat is news to me, and welcome. By the FAQ, it appears furnace filters must be covered. Box fans might be borderline, but even being seen publicly accused of violating gouging laws would be bad for HD.
- Johnny555 5y agoThe statute is broad enough (it includes "emergency supplies", and the CDC has a how-to guide on creating a box-fan filter) that I'm sure they'd be running afoul of the law if they tried to jack up prices for box fans. But yeah, any large retailer would avoid any appearance of price gouging even if they could get away with it legally just to avoid the bad publicity.
- neltnerb 5y agoI guess that explains why McMaster's price for N95 masks never really changed, they were just unavailable. Although on Amazon it was pretty wild to watch -- I guess if they're not technically N95 masks they can take the price as high as they want since they aren't actually recommended for protecting against viruses. But actual certified N95 masks just became unavailable instead of having high prices.
- hguant 5y ago>But actual certified N95 masks just became unavailable instead of having high prices. Part of that is because 3M has been incredibly good about not raising their prices, and has been very clear to its distributors that they're not ok with them raising the prices. Of course this does nothing to stop the hoarders/private sales jacking up prices on eBay...
- Johnny555 5y agoHome Depot has 3M N95 masks from time to time both in-store and for delivery, I picked up a 10 pack for a home improvement project a month or so ago. I only needed a few, so sent the rest to my immune compromised sibling.
- ransom1538 5y agoJust FYI! You want P100, not N95. People in ERs use P100 with a surgical mask ontop. ALSO! 3M is the only trusted supplier (it is hard to make P100s). Why did n95 get all the hype?? https://www.3m.com/3M/en_US/p/d/v000057510/ https://www.3m.com/3M/en_US/p/d/v000057510/
- Johnny555 5y agoP100's are significantly harder to breath in, and I'd question whether the typical user has a good enough fit to actually get the full filtering performance. I can't speak for ER healthcare workers, but I know from experience that hospital surgical nurses wear N95 masks. I'm not sure why anyone in healthcare would need a P* mask, since they aren't generally exposed to oil. If I really thought I needed a P100 mask, I'd get a rubber respirator with screw on filters -- they are easier to fit, and the dual respirators have more surface area for easier breathing.
- amluto 5y agoI would skip the misting. I haven't done the experiment, but a lot of modern filter materials get some of their filtering power from a built-in electrostatic charge, and that may not work if it's wet.
- ncmncm 5y agoThank you, good point I had not thought of. Anyway, they might be permanently degraded by too much moisture.
- drjasonharrison 5y agoThis is one of the reasons why N95 masks are hard to clean/sterilize AND return them to the original effectiveness. You have to remove the water that has condensed on the fibers. Vacuum pump appears to be an effective method.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThat said, if you don't have a filter, a wet cloth would work as a filtration medium.
- nazgulnarsil 5y agowouldn't you want the cheap filter first to pre-filter the air somewhat to make the more expensive one last longer?
- neltnerb 5y agoYes, pre-filtering out the big stuff makes finer and more expensive filters last longer. Interestingly, initially the captured particles actually make the filter capture finer particles in the future. The captured particles plug up the larger holes and themselves become part of the filter. Of course that doesn't last =)
- joveian 5y agoMy understanding (based on my not so great memory of an EPA air filter report) is that there are two basic types of this general type of filter and the electrostatic ones do best near the beginning and get worse over time while the others get better over time but with flow rate suffering. There are a few consumer air filter makers that do much better than most of them, particularly when it comes to the smallest particles, and I think they rarely if ever use the electrostatic ones for the inner filter. Those filters also cost quite a bit; I think the electrostatic ones can do a better job at low cost. For smoke in particular filters can easily aquire a smoke smell that makes them unusable well before they otherwise would be, unless there is a large carbon filter before it, so that favors low cost filters.
- dylan604 5y agohttps://www.amazon.com/Lasko-FF305-20-inch-Purifier-Purifying/dp/B089P1Z38J/ref=sr_1_2?crid=25MJS26DU2419 https://www.amazon.com/Lasko-FF305-20-inch-Purifier-Purifyin... I bought one of these, and have been happy with mine. I use a #10 filter in it. I have not needed mine for forest fire smoke (I know these higher rated ones are rated for smoke), but it has been amazing with pulling fine particulate matter from collecting (baking soda, mica, etc). This simplifies the taping/untaping, but before this purchase I did the tape method too. I was about to look for some aluminium channel to build a frame for the filter, but this product save me the time and hassle of that. Plus, this fan comes with a stronger motor to compensate for the filter.
- albrewer 5y ago> It is best to make them with a four inch thick filter, which HD does not stock I bought a 20x24x4 #10 pleated wool air filter at HD yesterday.