3 ms·
> When the majority of financial instrument controls are designed to limit the financial activity of the layman, who does it benefit? Just yesterday I was fight
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
> When the majority of financial instrument controls are designed to limit the financial activity of the layman, who does it benefit? Just yesterday I was fighting with my bank about how much I could spend on a single purchase. It was a startlingly low number. The amount I can actually withdraw from an ATM at any point in time is lower.
I have no experience like this, other than a bank contacting me if I am trying to use a card outside of my usual locations or outside of my usual amounts and I did not already alert them. Which sounds like a pretty reasonable anti fraud measure, and it only takes a couple minutes to solve.
And you can alert them prior to traveling or spending large amounts, and even do it online, so you are not inconvenienced at the time of purchase.
I also think it is easier than ever for the layman to buy whatever they want than ever. Everything is electronic and mostly instant. People can gamble on options sitting on their couch watching a game. You can buy equities for free. You can buy and sell in foreign currencies and Bitcoin with the clicks of a few buttons. All seems far more accessible than when I was a kid.
- all2 5y agoTry paying cash for something costing more than 10k USD. Things get hairy pretty quickly. [edit]And if your bank has no issues with that, then I'd love to know what bank it is. Mine was pretty sketchy about moving more than 3k at once per day.[/edit]
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI mainly use BoA, but while I have not had to withdraw or deposit $10k in paper cash in some time, as far as I know, the law requires you to fill out a form. But I wire much larger amounts of cash all the time online for real estate transactions, and I generally do not even have to talk to someone at the bank. I can do it all online. Edit: I have not needed to send $3k via Zelle yet, but according to BoA’s website, $3,500 in 24 hour time period should not be a problem: https://www.bankofamerica.com/online-banking/zelle-transfer-limits/ https://www.bankofamerica.com/online-banking/zelle-transfer-...
- salawat 5y agoTechnically, it just means extra paperwork. Tell their compliance department to hop to it. Just because it's uncommon, doesn't mean you shouldn't do it. In fact, the justification for these types of controls is normal people don't do those type of transactions. Think about that carefully, and you'll start to smell the rat decaying under the floor. In a way, the system is architecting itself to keep the fiscal freedom of the populace low to catch outliers that may just be criminals. I've just never been able to convince myself that there isn't some economic reality shaping going on there that people don't feel comfortable either talking about or admitting. If I can't easily do a transaction, but that transaction would be an example of good business that everyone wins from; I'd possibly be dissuaded from even trying. That seems counter to incentivizing good business to facilitate economic mobility.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe form being talked about here is form 8300, for paper cash transactions $10k and over. It is a pretty simple form identifying the parties in the transaction. https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f8300.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f8300.pdf I do not see how anyone can say it is difficult to comply with this, regardless of the issue of whether or not it should or should not be required. If there is any part of the system that is designed against lower socioeconomic classes, it is law enforcement (and TSA) being able to seize cash for no reason (civil asset forfeiture). But that has nothing to do with banks or the IRS.