2 ms·
I'd look to the Black Panther Party in the 1960s, and ask whether Americans have the same rights today as they did then. Couple of points I find interesting he
by klyrs 5y ago
I'd look to the Black Panther Party in the 1960s, and ask whether Americans have the same rights today as they did then. Couple of points I find interesting here.
(1) As I understand it, open carry is illegal in California and Washington as a direct response to armed BPP demonstrations on capitol buildings.
(2) Private enforcement like was carried out by the BPP was echoed in CHAZ/CHOP, and to put it mildly, I've never seen that celebrated by gun rights activists.
(3) The BPP and police forces of the time were fairly well matched in their armament. Since then, the police are now paramilitary forces replete with military arms and armor. Are American gun rights activists deluding themselves, that they'd stand a chance if the police and military decided they were gonna run shit? Or are they merely comfortable in the knowledge that the police and military are politically aligned with them?
- handrous 5y agoI do think the history of the Black Panthers is one of the more likely veins to yield gold, in my search, and intend to do some reading there. I'm entirely serious that I could turn around on this position completely, if I found compelling evidence. > (3) Are American gun rights activists deluding themselves, that they'd stand a chance if the police and military decided they were gonna run shit? Or are they merely comfortable in the knowledge that the police and military are politically aligned with them? It's largely the latter, I think, which brings me to: Ultimately, I think the fatal flaw in the argument that private gun ownership is necessary to protect democracy, is in the fact that authoritarian turns by democracies tend to be fairly popular, when they happen, and that the pro-authoritarian citizens, whose position is likely, if not the majority, at least quite popular, will have guns, too... plus the police, and the army (if they don't have those, what's the problem? No private arms needed, authoritarian take-over is done before it can start if the police and the military aren't on its side, or at least damn close to being on its side). It's not just a lack of history of private firearms being an important pro-liberty and pro-democracy force in democratic states (so far as I can see! Again, I'd love examples)—it's that I have trouble imagining scenarios in which they likely would be, while remaining within the realm of the plausible. It's got to be some movement that's unpopular among the military and police, so they don't support it, but popular among enough of the rest of the populace that significant numbers would take up arms, and that almost none of them would be taking up arms in against liberty and democracy, rather than for them... and is that a remotely likely situation? I don't think it is. I think for practically the whole likely problem-space, if you will, private arms are one of 1) superfluous, 2) laughably insufficient, or 3) actively harmful to the very things they're allegedly there to preserve & protect.
- anonfornoreason 5y agothe smart people who talk about guns as a way to resist a tyranny talk about asymetric warfare, the larger crowd of warrior lifestyle people just talk about rising up. I don't think very many Western people will throw away a comfortable life for any given set of principals, but I know many people who would fight if they were in a bad situation and felt like there wasn't much to lose. this is why a slow erosion of rights is very effective, by the time you get to the point you are willing to resist, you have given up enough rights that it becomes difficult or impossible.
- quantumBerry 5y agoThis is a very unpopular example, but Timothy McV*gh is probably the most well known example of someone who fought for a cause that in his mind was liberty from government in the united states using asymmetric warfare (he was very troubled by Waco and Ruby Ridge.) Of course, even those who are troubled by those events typically believe it was wrong that innocents such as children died in his acts. But if you really want to know what asymmetric warfare looks like, unfortunately it looks very ugly. The populace doesn't appear to give any indication they endorse the results. I honestly think most people would be very much worried about the legacy their reputation would have; even if they fought for a cause they believed in and avoided collateral damage. The combination of nearly universal social shaming for taking violent action (except when police do it, then it is "valorous"), consolidation of federal power, and the complete ineffectiveness of voting in slowing erosion of rights has been a deadly trifecta for individual rights such as the erosion of fourth and second amendment protections.
- Akronymus 5y ago> Are American gun rights activists deluding themselves, that they'd stand a chance if the police and military decided they were gonna run shit? In WACO a few "lunatics" took up the time of well over 1000 officers + a lot of hardware and well over a month. And this was just a few people with guns. The goal isn't necessarily to be able to stand up to the military, but rather to make a tyranny as unappealing and arduous as possible. I have a writeup somewhere, but can't find it atm, so I'll get back to you with it later.
- klyrs 5y agoBranch Davidians weren't that different from the Taliban, were they? Not exactly a shining example of guns preserving democracy...
- Akronymus 5y agoI don't think they were nearly as bad as they were made out to be. Also: It was meant more as an example that the 2nd provides a way to make it infeasable to practice tyranny over the US population through the military.
- klyrs 5y agoSure, child brides are totally chill in the Taliban too, if that's what you mean by not bad. Edit: My point here is that this is another example where private gun ownership allows upstart tyrannies to defend themselves. This is a negative example, not what handrous was seeking.
- Akronymus 5y agoThat's absolutely not what I meant by not bad. I specifically meant the that they were accused of having a stash of illegal weapons, which got the ATF involved. Where it is unclear who shot first, but a firefight broke out that killed a agent. Which then got the FBI involved and it spiraled from there. And you obviously can't forget the incendiary grenades later found in a evidence locker, labelled as benign, where the ID's indicated them belonging to the FBI. I am not defending child brides. But to me, it seemed like a VAST governmental overreach to be there in the first place. Where after the fact they tried to make the davidians look less sympathetic through the allegations. I came to this conclusion because those allegations never, not once, showed up before the siege. My point was that a few dozen people tied up over 1000 agents for over a month + lots of other resources. If just a few dozen such cases happen at or near the same time, it'd basically paralyze the whole governmental military apparatus. Also: I found the post again that puts my thoughts into good wording: https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/483595139562995722/883380040929267732/a7897089-63ce-4bab-990f-cb1e9f9af21b.png https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/483595139562995722/88...
- jpadkins 5y ago> that they'd stand a chance if the police and military decided they were gonna run shit? See Afghanistan. Full might of US military couldn't permanently suppress the will of the people. And afghans were significantly less wealthy, armed and organized than gun owners in america. There is no way the police and military could occupy the US without the support of the people. They would win every battle and lose the war, like Vietnam and Afghanistan. The modern military is very dependant on supply chains, and would collapse after 6 months if US workers revolted. Not to mention the massive defections if ordered to fire on their own people (why we swear an oath to the constitution and not an oath of allegiance to military commanders).