4 ms·
> How often do you build a prototype building? Or a building as a side project? This is one of the most amazing things about rapidly growing cities in most of
by jacobolus 15y ago
> How often do you build a prototype building? Or a building as a side project?
This is one of the most amazing things about rapidly growing cities in most of the world. Neighborhoods that start out as informal shanty-towns full of lean-tos with leaky roofs become, over the course of years, first neighborhoods with modest but permanent cement block buildings and tin roofs, and sprout all the typical urban amenities like power lines and sewers (often at first pirated ad-hoc from other nearby neighborhoods), have their roads paved, etc., and a few decades later look like normal neighborhoods, sometimes even surprisingly gentrified ones.
- badclient 15y agoAbsolutely, as someone who grew up in a city like Mumbai, I know much about shanty towns and from my knowledge of them, they are far from ideal. ie. They are not know for a strong foundation, cleanliness, longevity etc. They are constantly hacked and patched by its residents to ensure basics like protection from rain, electricity and basics like a toilet.
- raldi 15y agoAnd that's how New York and Rome and Shanghai grew into world cities. They didn't pave them over and start from scratch. They grew out of shantytowns.
- badclient 15y agoBut wait, we were talking about buildings, not cities. A city is made up of many buildings. And buildings are torn down across cities on a daily basis.
- michael_dorfman 15y agoRight, and chunks of code are thrown away on a daily basis. The question is: which is the more appropriate metaphor for a project? A building or a city?
- badclient 15y agoI agree with the position that it depends, code may be a building, or a city or any number of things. I disagree with the OP that deciding to recode can simply be compared to tearing down and making a new building for no reason. That's oversimplification. First, there are times when buildings must be demolished and built from scratch. The OP makes this idea seem ridiculous but it happens everyday when buildings are in fact demolished and rightly so. Second, fewer buildings are demolished and built from scratch relative to programming projects demolished and built from scratch due to the inherent differences between a coding project and a building project. For one, the former is more regulated and carries more physical risk than the latter(a coding project).
- oceanician 15y agoPeople might think coders are a bit self-important if we start analogising our project's as cities rather than buildings. Maybe some projects are more building innovation centres, that later go on to be used within actual buildings, and some don't get used.