6 ms·
Who should your computer take its orders from? (2002)
- paulddraper 5y agoFrom the App Store, obviously.
- smoldesu 5y agoYou'll be hard-pressed to find someone who doesn't think of Richard Stallman as a nut to some degree, but his predictions of how computing would centralize over the next few decades have absolutely come true. Nowadays, we don't think twice about apps you can't uninstall or processes you can't see, simply because that's now the de-facto way to develop software these days. And to a degree, I get it; we need to make concessions with computers when we market them to the masses. Even still, I can't help but feel like we made the wrong sacrifices. As companies like Apple, Samsung and Google make their surveillance increasingly intrusive, theirs audience becomes increasingly desensitized to their advances.
- hossbeast 5y agoWhy do we have to make those concessions? There are zero apps I can't uninstall or processes I can't see on my arch Linux desktop.
- smoldesu 5y agoWe need to make them because most people have a limited understanding of computer abstractions. I love Linux, and use it on pretty much every device I own. Even still, getting comfortable with Linux has a pretty profound learning curve with it's different WMs/DEs. As a developer, I highly appreciate the burden of choice here. End users likely won't feel the same way.
- hulitu 5y agoIf "most people have a limited understanding of computer abstractions" then don't make them. You know why people have a "limited understanding of computer abstractions" ? Because everything is hidden. "The user is stupid" they say. No it is not. 30 years ago when you logged in in CDE you were presented also with a help window and you had the chance to learn about your computer. My android phone needs an internet connection for help (older android 2.6 did not even had help). How do i connect to the internet to find out how to connect to the internet ? I am too stupid to be told something like this. I need abstractions.
- tharne 5y agoStallman's predictions would have been impressive had he made them even 15 years ago. But the fact that he was taking about these things back in the eighties when few people even owned computers is absolutely mind blowing. People spend WAY too much time focusing on Stallman's flaws and quirks and not nearly enough time on his ideas, which continue to be proven right over and over.
- na85 5y agoThat he has also done some very good things isn't a good argument for continuing to tolerate his harmful behaviour after he's been asked to fix it for literally decades, and hasn't. The guy is, at minimum, a total fucking creep who alienates women from the Free Software movement with his poor behavior. Furthermore if he's not a closeted pedophile then he sure devotes a lot of energy to defending pedophiles and finding ways to justify having sex with minors. The FSF is primarily a political advocacy project. Is RMS really who the Free Software community wants representing them to the rest of society? Really?
- tharne 5y ago> The guy is, at minimum, a total fucking creep This is exactly the kind of commentary I was talking about. The guy spots a serious problem 30+ years ahead of time, devotes his entire life to fighting it, while making tools that every developer uses every day, and all you have to say is, "He said some mean things, so let's reduce his entire existence to that". Thank God this mentality wasn't around during the second world war. We'd have stuck with Neville Chamberlain because he was such a nice guy compared to that drunken misogynist Churchill fellow.
- na85 5y agoI can't help but note you conveniently glossed over the fact that his continued bad behavior is directly harmful to the cause he's trying to lead. RMS is an actively detrimental force in the Free Software movement. He's a complete and total liability who hasn't made a substantive contribution to anything in 20 years. It's like people are purposely blinding themselves to the fact that if your cause is represented by a lunatic, it's less attractive than a similar cause led by someone who doesn't eat their toejam while giving a lecture. You have a person lacking even the most basic of social graces, who's consistently rude and unpleasant, who makes really gross comments about women and pedophiles, and this is who you think should be the public face of the movement? Why not literally anyone else? If the Free Software movement wants to be taken seriously, perhaps it should take itself seriously.
- paulddraper 5y agoI wonder why you're being downvoted....too pro-FOSS or not enough pro-FOSS?
- jamesgeck0 5y agoMaybe I've misunderstood the situation, but it seems like the free software community's distrust of TPM may have been a setback to desktop Linux security. Windows 11 will ship with what seems like reasonably robust TPM-based anti-rootkit security. Open source tools for using TPM exist, but does any Linux distro enable them by default?
- nsajko 5y agoBecause it's a pain in the ass with no security benefit in general. What attackers would it protect you from?
- joconde 5y agoTPMs enable hassle-free disk encryption, with no additional passphrase to enter at boot; I love that. It also prevents people from seeing me type the password (even better on Macbooks with a fingerprint reader, where I won't have to type my login password either.)
- IIsi50MHz 5y agoThen, naively, it would seem like anyone with physical access to the machine essentially has the drive decrypted for them auto-magical-ly at boot, defeating the purpose of encrypting. Of course, nothing prevents using additional encrypted containers within the filesystem for things of greater importance, but I digress… Regarding fingerprint: this is imaginary security, because people leave their fingerprints everywhere and social-engineering a person into placing fingerprints on something to be copied later is trivial. And if you go the extreme route of TV/film, fingers can be used after death or even removed. Now, as an additional layer of security, I like the idea of biometrics such as fingerprints. If Android would let me save fingerprints and enable recognition while still requiring lockscreen pattern, that would seem like a win.
- joconde 5y agoThe laptop boots, the key goes into RAM, then the OS asks for a login password. I don't see a simple way to get the encryption key or log in without the password. Unless cold RAM attacks got much easier recently, I don't see where the problem is for an average user. Fingerprints are admittedly not a match against someone willing to collect mine and make a model of them, but I'm not expecting anyone to do this. If I were, I would disable the fingerprint sensor, of course. The point of these features is that they make it very easy to get to a reasonably good level of security. If the only option were an (admittedly more secure) strong passphrase to type at every boot, nobody would use it, which would be much worse.
- kube-system 5y agoAs an engineer who doesn't use many cloud services, I personally agree with this perspective. On the other hand, there are a great number of "users" who have no interest in "using" their computers in as much as they are simply trying to accomplish some other task. Many average consumers just want to enjoy the outputs of their technology -- if someone else is giving the orders to the computer, that's not a drawback in their mind, if anything, it's a benefit. There is a reason why people are eating up cloud services, and this is it. RMS's argument made a lot more sense when computers were a professional tool used by trained individuals. But that audience has changed a lot in the past 30 years.
- jka 5y agoThere are some useful questions to explore around that; for example: Is there anything intrinsic about those tasks that means that control of those computing devices has to be rendered partially unto third parties by the everyday consumers who own them? Or, to put it another way: can the useful affordances that everyday users find in proprietary software equally be implemented in free and open source software?
- kube-system 5y agoIt depends on the particular circumstances. In the situations where FOSS wouldn’t work well for end users, there’s almost never a technological barrier to implementation, but tangentially related issues of ownership, control, expectation, obligation, law, or expediency. A lot of these situations pop up when a system consists of hardware, software, and information, and users that are all from different parties. Sometimes someone other than the user has a legitimate interest in a system.
- jka 5y agoGood food for thought - could you provide an example?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nsajko 5y agoI see people saying things like > we need to make concessions with computers when we market them to the masses or > RMS's argument made a lot more sense when computers were a professional tool used by trained individuals. But that audience has changed a lot in the past 30 years. So the argument is that users shouldn't have control over their own devices because most don't want it? That seems like a non sequitur. 1. Why not just hide the controls in a hard-to-reach menu or similar, if the goal is just not to frighten the poor device owners/users with control they don't want? Instead systems are purposefully engineered to lock them down. 2. There definitely seems to be a trend to take away ever more control that device owners used to have over the past decades and years. Apple leads the way with their phones and laptops, but I think that e.g., getting the right to administrate the OS on Android phones is also getting more difficult in general. So how come the users got by fine 15 years ago, without getting heart attacks from all the control over their systems available back then (compared to a today's smartphone). 3. I think it's pretty obvious that users will get less accustomed to having control over their devices if that control ceases to be available in off-the-shelf products, so the it's kind of backwards to just say "the users can't handle it".
- rightbyte 5y ago> There definitely seems to be a trend to take away ever more control that device owners used to have over the past decades and years. The pre-smartphone phones were in practice frozen. I vaguely recall installing some game on the later ones via cable to the computer though. But anyways, smartphones are more open in practice than phones used to be. So not all bad developement. (I am not mentioning the privacy drawbacks etc of new phones.)
- teitoklien 5y ago> smartphones are more open in practise than phones used to be Thing is a smart doesn’t compete with just a phone , it competes with laptops , desktops too. A lot of people don’t bother buying laptops or desktops these days because they can do most of what they want on their phone
- kube-system 5y ago
- axus 5y agoNice to see the addendum about TPM in 2015.
- anizan 5y agoA smartphone is an ankle monitor Android phones will blatantly ignore user choice to turn off location data and continue broadcasting to google and subseqent agencies. https://www.news.com.au/technology/gadgets/mobile-phones/google-will-keep-tracking-your-every-movement-like-it-or-not/news-story/7f6daa18cbe444cc11e2b1360e63f857 https://www.news.com.au/technology/gadgets/mobile-phones/goo...