3 ms·
Throwing away Netscape 4 and rewriting it from scratch wasn't a bad decision because nothing good ever came of it; it was a bad decision because it killed the c
by jerf 15y ago
Throwing away Netscape 4 and rewriting it from scratch wasn't a bad decision because nothing good ever came of it; it was a bad decision because it killed the company. The shattered remnant of Netscape that hobbled across the finish line to release "Netscape 6" wasn't even Netscape anymore, it was a rapidly fading division of AOL, IIRC, that just stamped its name on a Mozilla product it had little to do with producing at that point, to widespread derision.
As bad as Netscape 4/5 may have been, while I can't guarantee trying to refactor instead of rewrite would have gone better, I can guarantee it couldn't have had any worse a result than the Total Death that was the actual result.
And the phoenix-return of Mozilla is the exception, not the rule.
- fpgeek 15y agoTo be pedantic, there is at least one fate worse than the Total Death we observed: Total Death + no Gecko. Even though ths external case is stronger, this holds true even from the company's perspective. AOL continued to release Gecko-derived browsers through 2007. They got something from that (even if it was just AIM installs and propping up the fading Netscape brand for other purposes).
- alttag 15y agoIn support of your comment, I think some are forgetting how horrible Netscape 6 actually was to use. (Or am I just getting old? It wasn't that long ago!) Compared to earlier versions it was incredibly slow—even by the standards of the time—and crashed a bit more frequently. It took much longer to load or perform some common tasks. Sure, the rendering engine was better for many pages, but browser sniffers were still common, and (like now) weren't updated often enough, so bad versions of sites got served occasionally too. There were a host of reasons why Netscape 6 was bad from a user's perspective. Spolsky has it right when he says Netscape 6 was a piece of junk. Let's not allow time passing to permit us to remember it more fondly. Sure, future versions got better, but that was due to he creation of a new "corporate" memory. It took a while to get over having discarded so much learning.