4 ms·
> With federated services your are still just user@host, completely under the control of whoever owns host. Furthermore the federation aspect is completely opti
by pessimizer 5y ago
> With federated services your are still just user@host, completely under the control of whoever owns host. Furthermore the federation aspect is completely optional, if host decides to blacklists some other hosts, there is nothing you can do about it. So I don't see the advantage over the Twitter, Facebook and Co., when everything that makes federation special can be taken away at any moment.
These seem like advantages to federation. You can choose your masters, and you can choose another master (and they can choose to get rid of you) at any time.
I don't think that the advantage of federation over centralized services is that you can say and do what you want and everyone has to listen to or service you. It's that you have more options than one.
Of course, in the worst case, most nodes could federate into an exclusionary cartel controlled by a single, well-financed organization. But that means that the worst case for federation is the only case in the current situation.
-----
edit: I do think that the major thing missing from the web 2.0 user-provided content internet are tools to facilitate democracy and self-governance. With properly done tools and ownership structures, maybe the users can actually own their accounts, and have as much of a say in how their node was run as you would expect in an organization of peers.
- southerntofu 5y ago> You can choose your masters, and you can choose another master (and they can choose to get rid of you) at any time. That's only if your federated protocol supports account migrations (usually with some form of crypto-identity). This was pioneered as part of the Hubzilla ecosystem and ZOT protocol. Nowadays there are efforts to port this approach to ActivityPub/XMPP/Matrix, we'll see where that goes! Of course it's all easier if everyone owns their domain name and you can migrate "transparently". But the tooling for giving away free, pseudonymous domains is limited so far (afraid.org, netlib.re, eu.org..).